Just the other day, we showed again how wrong Roubini was. Here is the depiction again but in chart form:
Source: Brazilian Bubble and Nomura
Effort is not about how much you speak about your work, but how much your work speaks for you - Shihong, 2001
Showing posts with label Nouriel Roubini. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Nouriel Roubini. Show all posts
Tuesday, February 14, 2012
Thursday, February 09, 2012
The Inverse Roubini ETF?
Roubini, the master forecaster, is at it again. Roubini is currently bullish in the short term. I call him the master forecaster not because he was accurate in forecasting the 2008 financial crisis, but because he simply comes up with an amazing number of forecasts. Probably more so than a typical forecaster.
I have written about his forecasting abilities before, so I will not go on a Roubini-bashing spree again. But what caught my attention was this snarky comment on Roubini's bullishness:
Source: Brazilian Bubble
I have written about his forecasting abilities before, so I will not go on a Roubini-bashing spree again. But what caught my attention was this snarky comment on Roubini's bullishness:
We were caught up by surprise when we read a headline that said "Dr. Doom thinks rally has legs...". So, considering his awful stock market timing (he told everyone to stay "short" in 2009 and 2010, two of the largest rallies in history!), we thought perhaps it is time to consider our "Inverse-Roubini ETF" strategy.Shorting Roubini?
Source: Brazilian Bubble
Labels:
Nouriel Roubini
Friday, November 11, 2011
Volume 3 Issue 45: Two-Cent Economics
Roubini The Prophet (again?)
OK, I take it back. Roubini is not a loser. He does make a lot of extreme forecasts, but some of them actually make sense. For example, he spoke at Davos in 2006 about the dangers that the Eurozone was facing. I doubt anyone listened to him at that time. Here are some highlights:
But I can't say that he is alone in seeing this problem. I don't know enough about the Eurozone issues. But I think the fact that he saw this as a competitiveness issue shows some deep insight. I always feel appalled when I read about people saying that the trouble with Eurozone is that they have a monetary union without a fiscal union. That doesn't even begin to scratch the surface of the problem.
The lazy PIGS are quite simply, lazy and complacent. They have brought this upon themselves through years of resting on their laurels. It is going to be a painful period for the Eurozone, and for the rest of the world. Personally, observing the way things are going with the Eurozone right now, it feels a lot like watching a tragedy in slow motion. It is agonizingly painful. It would seem like you know a disaster is coming but you can't avoid it. Something like being on the Titanic as it is sinking.
As Tim Duy points out:
OK, I take it back. Roubini is not a loser. He does make a lot of extreme forecasts, but some of them actually make sense. For example, he spoke at Davos in 2006 about the dangers that the Eurozone was facing. I doubt anyone listened to him at that time. Here are some highlights:
In summary, there is serious growth divergence in the Eurozone area. This performance divergence is leading to serious tensions in fiscal and monetary policy. Given the growth slowdown and the political difficulties of fiscal adjustment when growth is mediocre, larger fiscal deficit are emerging in many laggard countries. These persistent violations of the GSP are a medium term threat to EM and to the ECB no bailout rule. Also, economic divergence and the tensions it is creating is leading to political pressures on the ECB to do more to stimulate growth, as the reaction of EU finance ministers to the ECB December 2005 decision to hike rates by 25bps shows.
This growth divergence is becoming a serious threat to EMU. As an increasing number of European observers are suggesting, different countries are coping differently to these challenges. Daniel Gros has shown that Germany has reacted with corporate restructuring, cutting labor costs and “competitive deflation”. I would argue that Italy has done little and is experiencing “stagdeflation”, a combination of stagnation and deflation. Indeed, as shown by Daniel Gros Italian labor costs have increased by 20% relative to those of Germany since EMU while Italy’s trade market shares have fallen by 20% relative to Germany. Similar competitiveness problems are faced by Greece, Portugal and Spain.
...
In conclusion, my view is that EMU can work and has worked for the Eurozone countries that have reformed and are reforming. But, unless Italy and other Eurozone laggards change their policies to pursue serious economic reforms that restore competitiveness and growth, they will eventually be forced to exit EMU. This would be a disaster but a disaster that may become unavoidable unless policies change. And I am currently pessimistic about the chances that such changes may occur given the policy makers and policies currently in place in countries like Italy.”In 2006, I guess I was still in the peewee leagues in terms of analyzing economies. Nonetheless, five years later, in 2011, the fact that things are turning out to be closer and closer to what Roubini described is enough to prove to me that he is no loser.
But I can't say that he is alone in seeing this problem. I don't know enough about the Eurozone issues. But I think the fact that he saw this as a competitiveness issue shows some deep insight. I always feel appalled when I read about people saying that the trouble with Eurozone is that they have a monetary union without a fiscal union. That doesn't even begin to scratch the surface of the problem.
The lazy PIGS are quite simply, lazy and complacent. They have brought this upon themselves through years of resting on their laurels. It is going to be a painful period for the Eurozone, and for the rest of the world. Personally, observing the way things are going with the Eurozone right now, it feels a lot like watching a tragedy in slow motion. It is agonizingly painful. It would seem like you know a disaster is coming but you can't avoid it. Something like being on the Titanic as it is sinking.
As Tim Duy points out:
There is no solution, no magic summit at hand. At this point, it is a choice between severe recession and depression. There is no happy ending to this story.Good times ahead.
Friday, November 04, 2011
Eurozone In One Paragraph and A Bit On Roubini
If it was ever possible to describe the Eurozone debacle in one paragraph, this would be it:
EconoMonitor : Nouriel Roubini's Global EconoMonitor » Full Analysis: Greece Should Default and Abandon the Euro: "Like a broken marriage that requires a break-up, it is better to have rules—divorce laws—that make separation orderly and less costly to both sides. Breaking up and divorcing is painful and costly even when such rules exist. But being stuck in a marriage of convenience that is not working any longer is more costly and painful for the couple and their offspring (children/future generations) than an orderly and civilized break-up. Once the pain and costs of the break-up are managed, both sides can look forward to a more friendly relationship and a brighter future."I have always been harsh on Roubini, but a good analyst should know when something someone says is right. The reason I am not too fond of Roubini is because he got lucky with the 2008 financial crisis prediction. He is the epitome of the following statement:
If you must forecast, forecast often, and if you’re ever right, never let them forget it.If you don't believe me, read here:
In 2006, a somewhat obscure economist stood before a room full of peers at the International Monetary Fund and let loose with some good old-fashioned doomsaying. The United States was about to get hit with a ghastly housing bust, he said. The price of oil was about to skyrocket, and a particularly nasty recession was on its way, bringing with it untold ruin and misery for citizens, bankers, and businesspeople all over the world. The prophesy was dismissed initially as the mutterings of a pessimistic crank. A year later, he was proved right beyond all doubt. “He sounded like a madman in 2006,” an economist who had attended the talk later told The New York Times. “He was a prophet when he returned in 2007.”
That economist was New York University’s Nouriel Roubini. And since he called the Great Recession, he has become about as close to a household name as an economist can be without writing “Freakonomics” or being Paul Krugman.
...
But here’s another thing about him: For a prophet, he’s wrong an awful lot of the time. In October 2008, he predicted that hundreds of hedge funds were on the verge of failure and that the government would have to close the markets for a week or two in the coming days to cope with the shock. That didn’t happen. In January 2009, he predicted that oil prices would stay below $40 for all of 2009, arguing that car companies should rev up production of gas-guzzling SUVs. By the end of the year, oil was a hair under $80, Hummer was on its way out, and automakers were tripping over themselves to develop electric cars. In March 2009, he predicted the S&P 500 would fall below 600 that year. It closed at over 1,115, up 23.5 percent year over year, the biggest single year gain since 2003.
How can this be? How can someone with the insight to be so right about a major event be so wrong about so many other ones? According to a recent study, it’s simple: The people who successfully predict extreme events, and are duly garlanded with accolades, big book sales, and lucrative speaking engagements, don’t do so because their judgment is so sharp. They do it because it’s so bad.
...
That one big call about the Great Recession gave him an unrivaled platform from which to issue ever more predictions, and a grand job title to match his prominence, but his subsequent predictions suggest that his foresight may be no better than your average man on the street. The curious nature of his fame calls to mind two of economist Edgar Fiedler’s wry rules for economic forecasters: “If you must forecast, forecast often,” he wrote. And: “If you’re ever right, never let ’em forget it.”Here is more on Alphaville and Real Time Economics:
Roubini has actually talked about this kind of thing before, in his now-famous 2006 speech to the IMF that predicted the crisis. Back then, he was forecasting a 70 per cent chance that there would be a severe recession.
Where did he get his number? Here’s what he said in the speech:
My analysis has been based on circumstantial kinds of observations. I am not a professional forecaster and I do not use a big global macro model. Even then I said the probability of a recession is “70 percent”. If you ask me where I got that number: just out of my nose, I will be very honest about that. I think if you said “50 percent” you look like a wimp, it means you are not sure. So if you have the guts of believing there is going to be a recession, you should say something higher than that, and that is where the “70 percent” comes from.
Get what I mean now?So my model is a ‘smell test’ or a ‘duck test’: if it looks like a recession and walks like a recession and quacks like a recession, it should be a recession. Or we can think of it as being the famous ‘obscenity test’: I’m referring to the Supreme Court Justice who said ‘I cannot define obscenity or pornography, but I know it when I see it’. So I see a recession that is based on this analysis and based on data and historical evidence.Just out of his nose? Well, there are worse places to pull a forecast out of. Though if 50 per cent makes you “look like a wimp”, what should using the 40% Rule do for your image?
Wednesday, October 12, 2011
Roubini Global Economics For Sale?
Even Roubini Global Economics is losing money. I guess I must say that it is not much of a surprise. When you make a billion predictions a year, you tend to get a few correct. But at the end of the day, the quality of your advice still matters. This is not to belittle the Nobel prize won by Roubini (edit: he didn't win shit), but some of his predictions are simply outrageous.
As my professor told me in my final year at university:
As my professor told me in my final year at university:
If you must forecast, forecast often. If you ever get it right, never let them forget it.In this case, Roubini is pretty much only remembered for "accurately" forecasting the 2008 financial crisis. I guess that's something no one is going to forget?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

