Showing posts with label Malaysian Budget. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Malaysian Budget. Show all posts

Sunday, June 26, 2011

Volume 3 Issue 26: Intelligent Investing

Why The ETP Will Fail




Many of you have praised Najib's initiative to transform Malaysia and most of the time, you would be correct to do that. When the New Economic Model was launched, I must admit, I was quite optimistic about Malaysia's prospects. However. as time passed, the New Economic Model decayed when the 10th Malaysia Plan was launched and it totally deteriorated when the Economic Transformation Programme was announced.

Why do I say this? Just a few weeks ago, I saw this piece of news. Here is an extract:


KUALA LUMPUR, June 16 — Asia Petroleum Hub (APH), a private company to develop and operate a multibillion-dollar oil terminal in Johor, has been placed under receivership by CIMB Bank, Singapore’s Business Times reported.
According to BT, the latest development could spell the end for a development once billed as one of the world’s largest fully integrated terminals with storage capacity of 924,000 cubic metres, large trans-shipment capacity and multiple jetties — all located on a 40-ha reclaimed island off the coast of Johor.

I would say that this is the first sign of many things to come in the next ten years. APH is a private company, just like how many of the projects in the ETP are supposed to be private ventures. As you can see from the extract above, they were trying to construct an ambitious project that sounds superbly promising, just like many of the projects in the ETP. So what happened? Here is what happened:

APH drew down RM840 million for project costs. But the executives said that project costs had escalated and APH was looking for investors for a further RM2 billion in new financing, the report said.

Surprise, surprise! The cost of the project was much higher than estimated, and they didn't have enough money. So now that they don't have enough money, what is going to happen to the half-baked oil terminal in Johor? Someone has to bail them out.

I am not saying that every ETP project is going to turn out like this, but let us assume, on the conservative side, about 20% of the projects run into cost overruns. That would mean that out of the RM1.4 trillion in projects that was planned under the ETP, about RM280 billion (YES, BILLION) worth of projects would end up in deep shit. Let's not kid ourselves. I don't even remember a time where an announced project did not meet cost overruns. So the figure would probably be a lot higher than 20%.

While Najib is out announcing all these impressive sounding projects all over town, let us ask ourselves, how is that going to improve our country? Pause for a moment and think about 10 years from now. With so much investment, let us even assume that our GDP would end up reaching the goal that was set out in the ETP. Do we honestly believe that our quality of lives would improve automatically without us having to work hard or improve at all?

This is precisely the self-denying, atrocious attitude that many Malaysians have. We think that just because the government announces 131 Entry Point Projects, our lives would automatically be better 10 years from now. We still need to improve our skills and knowledge and productivity and efficiency and competitiveness. Wealth isn't going to just drop down from the sky onto our laps. And since the key factor is to become competitive and productive and what not, why not make that our main goal instead of conjuring up 5001 acronyms to mislead the people into thinking that our lives will automatically be all right if we do all this big projects?

You really have to know your investments before you even start to investing.

Thursday, June 16, 2011

No Additional Cost

 
I want to laugh at this, but I just can't.

CYBERJAYA: The construction of the RM800mil new Istana Negara complex will be completed by the end of August without additional cost, said Works Minister Datuk Seri Shaziman Abu Mansor.

It is said as if there were cause for celebration that the new Istana Negara costs ONLY RM800 million to build. With RM800 million, you could have commissioned 400+ Facebook pages. Oh wait... that's free.

Wednesday, May 18, 2011

Volume 3 Issue 20: Intelligent Investing

Fuel Prices

Price per liter of fuel
Can't help but to post this as I saw it on Facebook. For those of you non-Malay speakers/readers, the above chart shows the price of one liter of petrol in the respective countries. All we hear is lament and complaints about how expensive the price of petrol is. Are those complaints warranted? Perhaps.

The funny thing about the list above is that, if you were to change the title to "Countries facing political uprisings", most of the countries would still be there. No prizes for guessing which. The problem is not so much in the prices of fuel, but the amount of budget deficit we are in and how distorted the demand for fuel has become. I would bet anyone a nickel that most of the countries in the list above do not even come close to having a persistent budget deficit like that of Malaysia.

Granted, the real problem is where the deficit came from to begin with, but that is another issue altogether. But just a heads up to you Main Streeters, the era of subsidized petrol is more or less over. If you guys don't think that some particular races are entitled to any "free" gifts, you should be more than willing to taste your own medicine. We are resourceful people. We will find ways to figure out this additional burden, just like how we have always figured out to solve any other problem.

Sunday, March 20, 2011

Volume 3 Issue 11: Intelligent Investing

Return on Investments (some thoughts)


Today from the Star:

Penang Hill funicular trains to attract more tourists
GEORGE TOWN: Trips up Penang Hill by the upgraded funicular train service will be as fast as five minutes or less in air-conditioned coaches but the public will only experience that in a month when the service resumes.
Tourism Minister Datuk Seri Dr Ng Yen Yen said the faster speed and new coaches that can accommodate 100 passengers each would enable 2.4 million tourists to visit the hill annually compared to 607,198 in 2009.
She said the hill received 65,176 visitors in the first two months of last year before the service was halted for the ministry’s RM73mil-upgrade.
“With the new and faster system, we expect there will be an influx of local and foreign tourists,” she said after handing over the project to the Penang Hill Corporation (PHC) on Saturday.
She said the project was in line with the ministry’s aim to build more parks and gardens.
“Penang Hill is a unique place for botany enthusiasts who love nature. I hope PHC will fully utilise its potential and make Penang Hill an icon in the state,” she said.
Chief Minister Lim Guan Eng, who is the head of PHC’s board of directors, said they would make an announcement in a month’s time on when the train service would be reopened to the public.
“We need to sort out several matters after we take over the project,” he said.
Prior to the upgrading, it took 30 minutes to go up the hill on the funicular service with a change of train in the middle station.
No change of train is required in the upgraded service.
Here are some simple calculations about how ridiculous some of the calculations are.

The Tourism Minister believes that the number of visitors to Penang Hill will jump to 2.4 million. I suppose you can't really find any fault with her because she did not say by when. Let us estimate when that will happen with some back-of-the-envelope calculation. Assuming a 25% growth per annum, it would take a little bit more than SEVEN years for the number of visitors to reach 2.4 million per annum.

So is the investment worth it? First of all, RM73 million sounds pretty steep to begin with. Let us now estimate how long it would take for the investment to recoup itself. Based on the current ridership and a 25% annual growth as before, with the ticket priced at RM8, which is double the current ticket price, it would also take SEVEN years to break even. Now, assuming that the ticket price did not double, and perhaps raised to RM6, it would take a bit more than EIGHT years to break even.

This is not even including all the operating costs, which includes maintenance, spare parts, etc. Should they have invested in this upgrade? Probably. But should it cost RM73 million? Could we have cut the cost to a much smaller amount? I sure hope so.


Friday, March 11, 2011

Police and computer system can’t cope with rush to settle summonses

 
This is from the Star. Naturally, this problem is not unexpected. It is well known that the government's system is always down, or insufficient to cater for the public's needs, or something or other. 
PETALING JAYA: The final deadline to settle traffic summonses was as chaotic as the last one on Feb 28 – hundreds thronged police stations frantic to settle by 10pm Thursday night.

Many went home disappointed as police stations informed them they had run out of queue numbers for traffic offenders to settle their summonses.

Supervisor Ayub Khan said he went on two consecutive days to the police station but could not get a queue number.

“The police told us to pay at the post office, but when I went to the post office they told me that their computer system was down due to the volume of transactions,” he said.

He added that the authorities should have improved the system so that it would not crash when the transaction volume increased. The Government had granted an extension on its Feb 28 deadline to March 10 after considering problems of long queues, lack of counters and a stalled computer system.

During the initial discount period, which began on Aug 12 last year, about 5.5 million summonses were paid, including the 1.5 million which were settled in the past week.

Some 17.3 million summonses remained unpaid when the last deadline expired on Feb 28.

From next month onwards, traffic offenders will be blacklisted and will not be able to renew their driving licences or road tax. A salesman, who wanted to be known as Choy, said he took a few days off to settle his summonses.

“I went to six different police stations and four post offices around Kuala Lumpur and Selangor and finally managed to pay here. Maintenance officer Ahmad Zul Hussin said he queued for three days and hoped to settle his five traffic summonses before the deadline expired.

When contacted, a spokesman from Pos Malaysia said its online services were temporarily congested due to the massive number of users trying to pay their bills online.

In GEORGE TOWN, Penang police collected RM24mil in summons payment from traffic offenders from August last year to yesterday, state police chief Datuk Ayub Yaakob said.

Police also recorded a huge increase in the number of people wanting to pay their summonses during the period, with a daily average of 500 to 600, he told reporters at the Timur Laut district police headquarters.

Ayub said from 2001 until 2010, only 57% out of 3.7 million summonses issued by Penang police had been settled. 
So, now what? Another extension? This would become likely, now that the cat is out of the bag that while many tried to pay, they were unable to. It would be unfair if they were not given the 50% discount, and much less if they were put on a blacklist.

It's amazing how one of the guys went to SIX different police stations and FOUR post offices, and still couldn't pay his summons.

Personally, I think the big push comes from the fact that election season is near. Conspiracy theorists would likely to believe so, and if another extension is given, it would increase the likelihood of such an event, simply because of two reasons. One, the government would appear to be "generous" by giving traffic offenders 50% discount. Two, they need money for the election campaign.

Monday, February 07, 2011

Are We Going to War?

RM6bil approved for six patrol vessels

LUMUT: The government has agreed to allocate RM6bil to build six second generation patrol vessels for the Royal Malaysian Navy, Defence Minister Datuk Seri Dr Ahmad Zahid Hamidi said Saturday.

The construction of the ships would boost the economy while benefiting 632 vendor companies, he told reporters here after a briefing on the project.

"Thus, we will ensure that at least RM2bil of the allocation will benefit these vendor companies which are strategic partners of Boustead Naval Shipyard Sdn Bhd," he added.

Ahmad Zahid said that he would himself monitor the progress of the project, due to start next year, and ensure that all concerned benefit from it and that there was no delay in paying the vendors.

He said that Boustead Naval Shipyard had constructed several new generation vessels for the RMN and shown itself to be on par with other ship builders in the world.

Ahmad Zahid also said the Lumut-Bagan Datoh coastal area here has been identified for a world-class shipyard to be developed over the next 10 to 20 years.

He said the defence industry, including shipping, had immense potential in the Asean region and now generated income of US$25bil (RM75bil) a year.

If Malaysia could attract at least 20 percent of the defence spending, US$5bil or RM15bil could be generated by companies in the country, he said.

Ahmad Zahid the government was now trying to attract more defence industry-based projects, including ship building, to the country. - Bernama

Source: the Star
Another awesome RM6 billion well-allocated. If one were not wiser, one would assume that Malaysia was planning to go to war with some country or other. I particularly like this line:

The construction of the ships would boost the economy while benefiting 632 vendor companies, he told reporters here after a briefing on the project.
One wonders how the construction would boost the economy. OK, it will add RM6 billion to GDP growth. Then what? Next year, we build another 6 more ships? This is very much the same as injecting steroids into the economy, which does nothing more than temporarily boost the GDP. Even if it were to create more jobs, the people who are hired to construct these boats would be redundant once the project is complete.

Ahmad Zahid said that he would himself monitor the progress of the project, due to start next year, and ensure that all concerned benefit from it and that there was no delay in paying the vendors.
I shall let you deduce for yourself what the above sentence implies.

Ahmad Zahid also said the Lumut-Bagan Datoh coastal area here has been identified for a world-class shipyard to be developed over the next 10 to 20 years.
Yes, the Lumut port is world class because of its depth which allows large ships to dock there. Why not let the private sector do what is actually world class? If you have a world class port, why are you using it to build second generation patrol vessels? This is akin to the Chinese saying, "Slaughtering the chicken with a knife for beef". In short, isn't this overkill?


Sunday, February 06, 2011

Volume 3 Issue 6: Two-Cent Economics

Ayamas Adventure

If you ever wonder why I sound so pessimistic with Malaysia's economic outlook, below is another story to add on to Malaysia's woes. If you find it difficult to grasp from the economics standpoint, the personal experience below should provide you with a clear picture of the kind of culture Malaysia has descended to.

One fine Saturday evening, after many years of having not patronized the Ayamas outlet at Batu Lanchang, Penang, I decided to give it another try after procuring some discount coupons from my cousin.

Walking up to the shop, I saw three of the staff who were standing at the entrance, chit-chatting away with one of their friends who brought along a baby in a stroller. They completely blocked the entrance and did not care less if a customer was trying to purchase something in the shop. After making eye contact with them, they decided to reluctantly step aside to allow me to enter to buy myself some Ayamas chicken.

Before I go any further, for those of you who are unfamiliar with Ayamas, it is a food franchise owned by KFC Holdings, which prides itself in serving "good" chicken. In my past visits, I have always ordered the "Perchik Chicken" which is roasted with a variety of spices that include hints of ginger, which I found to be very unique and somewhat tasty.

Perchik Chicken

So here I am, walking into the shop, looking forward to my "Perchik Chicken" and I saw another two employees sitting behind the counter chatting away. The first question that came to my mind was, "Why do they need 5 people working when the entire shop was empty?".

So I walked up to the counter and I asked for my Perchik Chicken and to my dismay, the staff told me that it was out of stock. Mind you that this was only 6.30 pm, which is dinner time for most people. They simply never cooked any. So after some deliberation, I decided to buy some of the original roasted chicken anyway and when I inquired about purchasing a bottle of chilli sauce that my family needed, the staff again replied with an air of arrogance that it was also out of stock.

At this point, one should wonder what was actually in stock. If you thought a little bit more, you might even think about what use are the five employees that are in the shop when they do not sell everything that I wanted.

How does this relate to Malaysia? Well, if you don't already know, some ministers in Malaysia claim that the country is in full employment (Malaysia's unemployment rate is around 3.5%). What is the use if the full employment is attained from hiring redundant workers that burden the sustainability of any company? Should companies be forced to do "national service"?

It is because of the rampant incompetent workers that the Malaysian education system develop which creates excessive employment in the low-skilled jobs sector, while leaving huge gaps in the high-skilled jobs. One of the top five reasons for job vacancies in the services and manufacturing sector is because of no applicants. This is extremely shocking because for whatever reasons, Malaysians feel that they don't need to work as they leave job openings unfilled. This would be unheard of in India as millions struggle in poverty and hunger and would do almost anything for a job.

There is simply insufficient hunger in Malaysia. Many people do not feel hungry because the government has subsidized fuel, flour, cooking oil and many other things. They do not feel the pain of being unemployed because goods are kept at low prices. You may ask, "Isn't this good for the public?" Well, in the short run, it makes a small group of people happy, but who is going to pay for all the subsidies in the long run?

To make matters worse, it is because of the persistent subsidies that an economic problem has turned into a social problem. Many Malaysians have lost their hunger and have become complacent.




Sunday, October 24, 2010

Economics @ Home © Volume 2 Issue 22

Troubled times - 100-storey style

These are troubled times indeed. With the launch of the 2011 Budget, how can a self-respecting newsletter proclaiming to discuss economics not talk about it?

By now, most of us would have read and heard and discussed and bitched about how the government is wasting the people's money in trying to build a new 100-storey mega tower. The government has subsequently rebutted by saying that the money used will not be the people's money, but belongs to PNB. So, this week's issue will avoid repeating the gory and now already boring details about the 100-storey building.

Econ @ Home will take a look at what the 2011 Budget means for regular Malaysians at home. After all, that is what the newsletter is for. Bringing down economics at the macro level to the micro folk at home. Making common sense, common.

For starters, bear with me for elaborating a little bit more about the Warisan Merdeka mega tower. Most people who bitch about this issue claim that the money is being wasted on a useless mega-tower and have recommended using the money in places like health, education, security and what not. Everyone wants a little piece of this hot pie. But what the country needs is not spending in these areas. haven't you all learnt your lessons? The government can spend money in these areas. We have seen the likes of RM48,000 laptops, and the like. The trouble with the Malaysian economy is in its policies. Where the money is spent is just secondary.

Now that that part is settled, what does the 2011 Budget mean for folks at home like us, the common folk that try to earn an honest living to spend on the needs and wants of our lives?

First of all, the lack of any initiative to reform the policies bodes huge ills for the nation. The ETP is a huge disaster compared to the NEM that was launched in March this year. Econ @ Home is not anti-government. But Econ @ Home is anti-stupidity. With such a well-written plan like the NEM available, it requires almost no intelligence to go along such plans. How can improving productivity and competitiveness be so bad?

How can Malaysia and Malaysians keep denying to themselves that nothing is wrong with our policies? The government's current stance is, "Don't worry, this time, business is not as usual. That's because the private sector will be the one spending the money." Why have they not realized that it does not matter who is the one spending the money. My favorite simile for such a situation is, "Be it the government or the private sector that adopts the white elephants, they will still be white elephants". The joke of the whole situation is, the government is telling the private sector where to spend their money. This is made worse when our infamous bankruptcy prophet, Idris Jala says that, "If the projects fail, it will be the private sector's fault". I do not need to elaborate further the irony of the issue.

Second, what do minimum wages mean for us? Sadly, on the surface, to most of us, it means nothing. This is because Malaysia as a whole, is being squeezed in the middle income trap. But is it true that it does not affect us? Let me just touch on why minimum wages are bad in an unproductive and uncompetitive country like Malaysia. Mind you, this is just simple economic theory that anyone who studied Economics at the pre-university level can tell you (Hmmm... I think I need to qualify what pre-university means because Matriculation is a lazy student's excuse of a pre-university education). You may ask, "How can minimum wages be bad?" It raises the wages of the poor, and subsequently, their standard of living.

Ordinarily, this would be a good idea if the country was a productive one like Germany or China. But mentioning Malaysia along the names of those industrious countries is like blasphemy. When you impose minimum wages, you will immediately raise the costs of hiring for companies. While local companies have no choice by to absorb these costs, MNCs do not have to deal with this. All they have to do is set up a new factory in Vietnam and voila, they would have cut their wage expenditure by 75%. Can we afford to lose the few meager FDI that still remain within the country?

What does this mean for local companies? Since they can't really move out of the country at their whim, they have 2 options. First, cut expenditure elsewhere. They may have to cut expenditure on advertising, research and development, and even training budgets. Cutting advertising will ultimately lower sales, and reducing expenditure on research and training simply means the firms have no hope of moving up the value chain. Lower resources also mean that firms are unable to bid for the talent that they seek. How are we going to achieve competitiveness? Their second option is to pass the cost of hiring to the consumers. Now, guess who the biggest group of consumers are? If you guessed the middle class, then you are most likely to be correct. It is us, the hardworking people who struggle to make an honest living who have to bear the burden of higher prices because of increased costs. Since the middle class does not fall into the levels of minimum wages, it does not help them at all. So how can the middle class cope with increased costs of living? Simple, by demanding higher wages. Now, I hope you can see where this is going. In economic theory, this is called the wage-price spiral. Higher prices drive wages higher. Then higher wages will drive prices higher.

Now, the issue on services tax. What does the increase of 5% to 6% mean for us and for the government? Well, needless to say, the majority of our expenditure will be consuming services. Let's say that 70% of our expenditure is on paying for services. That would entail a raise of 0.7% in our typical expenditure pattern. That is by all means palatable. What does this mean for the government? If you look at the economic report downloadable from the Ministry of Finance's website, you will notice that revenue from services tax will increase ONLY from 2.4% to 2.5% of revenue. That is a 0.1 percentage point increase in revenue. One can only wonder, what is the rationale for this? If the government wishes to raise funds to fund their mega projects, why not just rationalize the subsidies or trim down the bulging civil service. Can you imagine that 28% of the government's money is spent on paying civil servants in emoluments? Of the total labour force, only about 10% are from the civil service. What this means is that, 28% of the government's money is spent ONLY on paying 10% of the hardworking people of Malaysia. This is not even counting the pensions and gratuities and whatever other benefits the civil servants have.

I hope that these 3 issues will open your eyes further on how the 2011 Budget affects the typical Malaysian at home. I tried not to dwell too much on the 100-storey tower simply because all of you have already over-discussed it. By the way, as a trivia, as at time of completion of this article, there are 144,004 supporters on the "1M Malaysians Reject 100-storey Mega Tower" page.