Showing posts with label Inflation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Inflation. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 18, 2011

Volume 3 Issue 20: Intelligent Investing

Fuel Prices

Price per liter of fuel
Can't help but to post this as I saw it on Facebook. For those of you non-Malay speakers/readers, the above chart shows the price of one liter of petrol in the respective countries. All we hear is lament and complaints about how expensive the price of petrol is. Are those complaints warranted? Perhaps.

The funny thing about the list above is that, if you were to change the title to "Countries facing political uprisings", most of the countries would still be there. No prizes for guessing which. The problem is not so much in the prices of fuel, but the amount of budget deficit we are in and how distorted the demand for fuel has become. I would bet anyone a nickel that most of the countries in the list above do not even come close to having a persistent budget deficit like that of Malaysia.

Granted, the real problem is where the deficit came from to begin with, but that is another issue altogether. But just a heads up to you Main Streeters, the era of subsidized petrol is more or less over. If you guys don't think that some particular races are entitled to any "free" gifts, you should be more than willing to taste your own medicine. We are resourceful people. We will find ways to figure out this additional burden, just like how we have always figured out to solve any other problem.

Monday, May 16, 2011

Volume 3 Issue 19: Intelligent Investing

How Inflation Swindles the Equity Investor


Here is a link of Warren Buffett talking about inflation. It is a very long article, and I highly encourage it for those of you who are interested. Those of you who can't get through the reading, well, this is how you tell, investing is not for you. Research involves a lot of reading and there are no two ways about it.

Sunday, January 30, 2011

Volume 3 Issue 5: Two-Cent Economics

Finding Inelastic Demand to Fight Inflation




In the previous issue of the Mainstreeter, we brought up how companies that produce goods with price inelastic demand could raise prices to pass on the effect of higher costs to its customers. This would in effect, pass on inflation to their customers, and thus buffering their profits.

While we can go into great detail about what price elasticity means and talk about its mathematical derivation for the sake of precision, we should keep in mind the goal of using this concept as a tool to help us look for good companies to invest in.

Because of that, we would only venture as far as the intuitive definition of price elasticity. In the broad sense, as the term elasticity suggests, price elasticity of a good measures the sensitivity of its quantity demanded to a change in price.

In all our explanation, we shall assume that the goods we are discussing face normal demand curves, in that when the price of that good increases, the quantity demanded will fall. Now for the formal definitions.

A good that is price elastic is one which would have a more than proportionate decrease in quantity demanded for an increase in price. Conversely, the quantity demanded for a price inelastic good would decrease by less than the proportionate price increase. 

Here is a better illustration. For example, if the quantity demanded for cheesecakes fell by 15% (more than 10%) when the price of cheesecakes increased by 10% during the Chinese New Year, then the demand for cheesecakes would be classified as price elastic.

In the case of vegetables, the 10% increase in price during the same season caused the quantity demanded for  vegetables to drop by 5% (less than 10%). This means that the demand for vegetables are price inelastic.

While it may need a bit more justification, I would just like to point out that when the demand for a particular good is price inelastic, an increase in price would raise the total revenue received for selling the good. This is because the rise in prices more than offset the decrease in quantity demanded. Also, a relatively price inelastic demand curve would allow the producer to pass on rising costs to consumers by raising prices. Bear in mind that it is in this context that we are looking at price elasticity.

Now that we have the definitions out of the way, what causes the demand for goods to be price inelastic? That is what we want to look for when we are analyzing the products of the companies that we are researching.

1. Availability of substitutes

This is intuitive. If the good that the company we are looking at produces has many substitutes, it would be less able to raise prices because its customers could easily switch to buying from the company's competitors. Hence, we want to invest in companies that produce goods which not many other companies can produce. For example, aeroplane engines. Not many companies in the world can produce aeroplane engines apart from Rolls-Royce. In addition, the quality of the engines also play a huge role because of the safety requirements needed in the aeroplane industry and not many people can match that.

2. Price as percentage of income

When a good costs very little as a proportion of our income, we tend to pay less attention to its price increases. Hence, the good would be relatively price inelastic. If we are talking about say, a car, then any amount of price increase would create a bigger deterrence to purchase as the car comprises a large portion of  our income.

3. Degree of necessity

This ties in with the vegetable example. Goods that are perceived as necessities tend to be price inelastic. Another example would be banking services. Most of us need to use banks for savings, loans, credit card purposes.

4. Brand loyalty

Well, this is pretty self-explanatory. Some of the more famous brands I can think of are probably Coke, Apple, and Intel. Barring anything that would give these names bad reputation like what Toyota is facing, it would be difficult to disrupt the brand loyalties that these companies have. Hence, an increase in prices would unlikely change the preferences of their customers.

That said, it would be rather difficult to find companies that produce goods that have all of the above factors. Nonetheless, we can look for goods that have as many of the above-mentioned qualities as possible. Bear in mind that there are a few other minor factors that I left out, but these should be a good enough guideline to get you started.

Of course, price elasticity may not have to be applied to only consumer goods. It can be applied to intermediate goods as well. So, when you try to think of goods that are price inelastic, do not limit yourself to end-products. Think of the ingredients and parts as well. These will help you find companies that can maintain robust earnings through inflationary periods. This is particularly important as we are possibly experiencing a period of high inflation right now. Firms that are not flexible enough to pass on the rise in raw material costs will take a hit in their profit margins and could even suffer losses in the coming quarters.

That could be a good excuse for the stock market to cool off even more and provide some buying opportunities.

Tuesday, January 25, 2011

Volume 3 Issue 4: Intelligent Investing

Investing in Inflation - Part 2



In Part 1, we established how inflation is one of any investor's worst enemy. In this issue of the Mainstreeter, we will take a look at some of the possible ways to invest, and will venture into explaining why investing in equities can possibly counter inflation better than all the other investment vehicles.

In Economics @ Home Volume 1 Issue 11, we discussed other possible means to invest because of the fact that placing your money in fixed deposits is a slow but sure way of becoming poorer. Here is an extract from that issue:

"Although more and more people are becoming aware of investing their money in the stock market, many are still wary of its risks. People are afraid of the unknown and are even more lazy to learn about the stock market. I am not here to allay your fear of the stock market, but merely to explore some alternatives that might actually generate some real positive returns. I will tackle these investment vehicles in the order of least practical to the most practical in my own point of view. I take no responsibility for the performance of these investments because most of them require some amount of knowledge and skill as well as a lot of hard work. After all, there is no such thing as a free lunch. I cannot and will not advise anyone to just dump your money in any of these vehicles and hope that they generate luxurious returns because that is not possible and it is also illegal for me to induce purchases in some of these investments because I do not have an investment advisor license.
1. Fixed Deposits
I cannot mention enough how useless these instruments are in terms of growing your funds. The era of high interest rates are gone. With expected inflation to be low in the coming years, there is very little chance for interest rates to be scaled upwards. Even so, on average, fixed deposit interest rates merely track inflation over the long run. In fact, the yield spread could even be used as a predictor of expected inflation. That exemplifies how strong the correlation is. So, there is no way of beating inflation if you place your funds in fixed deposits. However, it is important to note that these investments are basically risk-free.
2. Amanah Saham Bonds (and other Amanah Saham stuff)
I feel these funds are more for entertainment value than for anything else. Even, the ones that guarantee 5% returns for the next however many years still have very little potential to beat inflation. Nonetheless, these instruments are slightly better than fixed deposits, which is why many people are willing to spend hours waiting in line at the banks to subscribe to these funds. An even funnier fund is the one that invests in equities. It promises to track the KLCI. There is almost no skill in that because any person with a trading account can basically allocate his funds equally throughout the KLCI counters and you would basically get the same performance, but without incurring management fees.
3. Property Investments
This one is pretty debatable. While it may generate potentially high returns, I feel it is not practical for beginner investors like you and me because of three reasons. First, its initial capital outlay is extremely high. The down payment to purchase property is very high, which may tie up our funds to invest in other opportunities as and when they emerge. Second, property investment is extremely illiquid. This ties in closely to the first reason because it is extremely difficult to dispose off these investments when we want to realize our gains or purchase other opportunities that we deem to be better. Third, in most cases, we have to incur guaranteed costs while our incoming cash flow is unpredictable. That is to say, we have to pay monthly instalments on our loan while we may have difficulty renting out the property, assuming that the property is already completed.
4. Unit Trusts (Equity funds, to be specific)
This category is huge. There are tons of different types of unit trusts. However, I will focus mainly on equity funds because the rest are just a combination of 1, 2 and equities. First of all, let me explain what a unit trust is. Basically, it is a collection of funds from investors with a particular set of investment objectives placed in the hands of a fund manager to invest according to those objectives. Equity funds is a unit trust fund that invests predominantly in equities (stocks, if you're unfamiliar with the term equities). One of the main attractions of equity funds is that the potential returns tend to be higher. Nonetheless, this is debatable because the performance of the fund greatly depends on the abilities of the fund manager. So, due diligence is still needed when selecting a fund to invest in. Like I have preached before, there's no such thing as a free lunch.
Why do I feel that this is more practical than the previous three investment vehicles? First, the concept of unit trust allows one to invest with very small capital. Minimum initial investments are around RM1,000. Second, if we can find an able fund manager, we can ride on the "expertise" of the fund manager to obtain better than average returns. Typically, decent performing unit trusts average about 8% per annum in the long run. That is far higher than your long run FD rate. As to why the returns are so high, it is because the funds are invested in equities, which are companies listed in the stock market, which (hopefully) run a good business to churn a good profit that allows high returns on investments.
The drawback of unit trusts is, however, the management fees that you have to pay the fund manager. While this is not a fee that you have to fork out money and pay regularly, but it will be deducted from the fund based on the performance of the fund manager. Usually, this fee tends to be rather high. In addition to that, there is a commission that needs to be paid to the agents of unit trusts for marketing the unit trusts for the company. These fees can sometimes eat into the returns of our investments. Nonetheless, unit trusts tend to outperform plain deposits in the long run.
5. Equities
This is the most interesting and possibly the most promising investment vehicle of all. While diving into share investment without any knowledge is risky, knowing what you are doing reduces most of the riskiness involved. It is true that the risks of investments are there, but due diligence to ensure a high margin of safety minimizes the risks involved. Ben Graham, the guru of value investing said "Investing is most intelligent when it is most business-like". This sentence sums up what investing is all about.
Imagine yourself starting a business. Think of a list of criteria of how you want your business to be. These are the criteria that you should be looking for in the companies that you invest in. I do not condone speculation and will never do so. I am an advocate of value investing and the idea of value investing is simple. It is like paying RM5 for something that is worth RM10. If this does not attract you, then it will never attract you at all.
While the idea is simple, the work is hard. Most people would preach the risk-return trade-off in investing by saying that in search of higher returns, we must take more risks. This is totally untrue. What I know to be definitely true is that in search of higher returns, we must do more work. The key phrase of this issue is "due diligence"...
...you should note that one of the most important things in investing is that there is no formula for it. There is no one true way to grow your money. There are many ways to grow your resources. Some are able to grow it at a faster rate, some at a more conservative rate. One thing for sure is that nothing comes for free. Effort is essential."

While it is obvious that I have a huge affinity towards investing in stocks, it does not mean that all other investments are inferior. As I mentioned above, there is no one true way to making huge returns. However, to return to the point of this issue, how can investing in equities beat inflation?

For starters, the potential returns are much higher than fixed deposits and the inflation rate, of course, with the caveat that you do your homework.

The second bolster to inflation is from the firms' abilities to pass on their costs to consumers. There are certain businesses which have the ability to pass on rising costs to their customers through increases in the prices of goods sold. The kind of businesses that have this ability are those that have a price inelastic demand. There are many reasons that may cause the demand for certain goods to be price inelastic. They include the degree of substitutability, degree of necessity, price as a percentage of income as well as degree of loyalty from consumers. We will discuss these factors in a later issue.

What I hope to point out is that in face of inflation, strong businesses are able to maintain their earnings because of their ability to pass on the increase in the prices of raw materials to their customers, fully or partially. This allows them to buffer their earnings. And as an investor, or rather, an owner of such a company, hearing this is good news. This is because the company's earnings would rise in tandem with inflation. In the long run, the value of our investments would rise along with inflation as well, thus protecting our investments from being eroded by inflation. We would be literally investing in inflation.

In short, this would be an extra criteria when looking for companies to invest to add on to our margin of safety.

Thursday, January 20, 2011

Volume 3 Issue 3: Intelligent Investing

Investing in Inflation - Part 1



How is this even possible? In this two-parter, I will discuss on how one can invest in such a way that you are "protected" from inflation. Before that, let us first recap and discuss what inflation means and how it affects us.

In the most common of terms, inflation is defined to be a consistent increase in the general price level of goods and services within an economy. If this still sounds too complicated, just think about the price of a cup of Milo at your favorite coffee shop five years ago. It would probably have cost you RM1.00. Today, it is quite likely to cost closer to RM1.50 or RM2.00. That is how inflation is observed in one good. But if only the price of Milo is rising, then it is OK because we can simply switch to other beverages if we decide not to pay too much for Milo. So it is insufficient to label the increase of the price of Milo as inflation.

As I mentioned, inflation is the consistent rise in the general price level. That means that most of the commonly used goods and services are becoming more expensive year after year. It is also insufficient to label price hikes due to certain natural disasters such as floods or earthquakes under the category of inflation. Inflation is reflected in the consistent rise in prices. It does not count when prices go up for 3 months, and then fall back down to the normal level. Inflation is when prices keep going up and up.

Now that we are clear what inflation is, how does it affect us? Most people on the Main Street choose to save their money in the bank. The more careful ones would even place their money into fixed deposits to get a higher rate of return. Let us first consider the simplest of cases. Jim keeps all his savings under his pillow, where he earns zero returns. In the past 10 years, the inflation rate has averaged around 2.2%. This means that prices of goods and services have gone up at around 2.2% per year for the past 10 years. So if Jim were to have saved RM1,000 under his pillow at the start of 2001, the purchasing power of that same RM1,000 would be equivalent to that of RM815.28 today. He can buy much less with the RM1,000 than he could 10 years ago.



Clearly, from this example alone, we can see that inflation erodes the value of our money. What happens when we place our money into fixed deposits? Now, consider Sam, who placed his RM1,000 into a fixed deposit account in a Malaysian bank at the beginning of 2001, and reinvests the capital plus interest at the beginning of each year at the prevailing rate. At the end of 2010, Sam would have saved up RM1,427.99. What a difference this makes compared with Jim who did not put his money into any kind of interest-bearing vehicle.

Let us now factor in inflation. At the average of 2.2% per year inflation rate, the purchasing power of the RM1,427.99 is equivalent to that of RM1,164.21. Imagine that! After 10 long years of saving his money in fixed deposit, Sam has managed to attain a real (inflation adjusted) return of 16.4%, which translates to roughly 1.5% per  annum. I don't need to elaborate further how sad the returns of fixed deposit are.

What makes things worse is that, the only reason Sam is making a positive return is because Malaysia is a highly subsidized country. This means that a lot of the prices of goods are controlled by the government, such as fuel, electricity, water, flour, sugar, cooking oil, fertilizers, etc. Hence, in actual fact, prices of goods around the world have risen at a much faster rate to much higher levels.


Just imagine if the general price level had risen at the same rate as that of the World's Consumer Price Index. The average inflation rate of the whole world in the past 10 years is about 3.9%. This is how much the Malaysian government has distorted the prices of goods and services in Malaysia. But that is another story for another day.

Now, let us recalculate Sam's purchasing power after 10 years after adjusting for the world's inflation rate. After 10 long years of saving in fixed deposits, the purchasing power of Sam's RM1,000 in 2001 will be equivalent to RM976.18 today, which is LESS than what he started with.

How is this even possible? Well, this was made possible by the simple fact that on average, the inflation rate exceeded the interest rate offered by the banks. Given that Malaysia is trying to cut all the subsidies that it possibly can, this is going to be what saving your money in fixed deposits will look like in the next 10 years.

It has been clearly illustrated that inflation can be one of the greatest enemies of investing. It will erode your purchasing power, whether you like it or not. In the great words of one of my friends, "Putting your money in fixed deposits is a way of getting poorer slowly, but surely". This makes it even more important to learn how to invest. We will discuss our options in beating inflation in the next part.