Showing posts with label Elections. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Elections. Show all posts

Friday, June 08, 2012

Volume 4 Issue 24: Intelligent Investing

Education of Ministers

The past week of political news have been tragically funny, probably in a way that I should not be laughing. Based on the things that were said by some of our ministers no less, one can only wonder how and where they were educated. It was as if it was not bad enough that we actually have a Member of Parliament who talks like this:


Here are the news reports that surfaced in the last week or so:


On 6 June 2012, the Road Transport Department claimed that our Health Minister, Liow Tiong Lai must pay for the car number plates that he allegedly "bought". And the following day, this is what Liow said:


Great. This is ingenious. Needless to say, this will probably be one of those cases that is going to be swept under the rug and thrown in the darkest hole of the deepest dungeon and never to be heard of ever again, or at least, until after the elections.

Then the following day comes another "genius" who believes that freezing student loans is a great idea for making an example out of the opposition party. It is beyond distasteful and what happened the following day demonstrates the simple lack of common sense that is demonstrated by our Minister of Education no less.


Of course, the repercussions of such a move would have been disastrous. The stupidity was retracted the following day:


This is how I picture Najib after he read what Muhyiddin said:

Of course, this is nothing new to our infamous Deputy Prime Minister. He is well known for his brilliant deductive reasoning using basic "facts". This is another one of them:



Based on the above examples, the nauseating feeling that I get when I know that our country is relying on the best brains such as those above to run our country keeps me up at night. And then nostalgia dawns upon me, reminding me of the days when Malaysia used to point at Indonesia and laugh at how far behind they are compared with Malaysia.

The last 10 years or so tell a very different story about Indonesia. They too, once suffered for a long time under incompetent leadership, but everything changed after a severe Asian crisis that kicked them in the nads, and this woke them up.

So, I did a little experiment, and tried to find out where and how some of our ministers are educated, and compared this with our apparently "inferior" neighbors - see Table 1.


The Vice President of Indonesia has a PhD from UPenn, while our great DPM is a great graduate of our greatest university, UM, with a big Bacherlor's Degree. And I think the rest of the list speaks for itself. Given the huge difference in the quality of education between the ministers of Malaysia and Indoensia, is it any surprise that Indonesia has been outperforming Malaysia year after year?

But of course, our great DPM would beg to differ. After all, Malaysia's education system is better than advanced countries isn't it?



Volume 4 Issue 23: Intelligent Investing

The Election Dream

With all the fuss about the General Election being around the corner, it has become impossible to go one day without seeing or hearing some politically related message, either from the newspaper, on websites, or even on Facebook.

If you lived in the world of Facebook, there appears to be an overwhelming feeling of anger/frustration towards the present government and if the world (or Malaysia, at least) revolved only entirely around Facebook, it would seem that the election results would be foregone conclusion.

The time for change is here. Governments all over the world are changing. It started with the Arab Springs in Tunisia, Egypt and then Libya. Then even Europe had several changes in government, albeit for completely different reasons. There was also Occupy Wall Street. There appears to be a general feeling for wanting change everywhere.

When I look at my News Feed, I get the feeling that the support for Pakatan Rakyat is overwhelming. Day after day, alleged scandals appear regarding ministers and cronies of the government. The feeling I get is that most people are outraged.

But what has always bugged me was that East Malaysia contained a disproportionate number of seats and in order for Pakatan Rakyat to make any headway, they need meaningful support in East Malaysia. In the 2008 Elections, Pakatan's showing in East Malaysia was abysmal. Just take a look at the results below:

Chart 1: 2008 Election results by number of seats won
First, let me state the obvious. We all know that Pakatan gained tremendous ground in most of the urban states (i.e. Penang, Perak, Selangor). They also won in Kelantan. But as Chart 1 shows, Sarawak, Johor and Sabah has the most number of seats up for grabs. Out of a total of 222 seats, those three states take up 82 seats, or 37% of the total. And in those three states, Pakatan only managed to win ONE seat each. So in those three states alone, BN had locked in more than 35% of the total seats.

But this is not what bothers me. What bothers me was that Sarawak, despite being a relatively large state, is sparsely populated. In terms of population, Sarawak has about 2.4 million people, which is about 8.8% of the total population. But the 8.8% of the total population are voting for 31 out of 222 seats, or 14.0%.

However, that is not the only state in which there is a huge discrepancy between its proportion of population against its proportion of seats available. No prizes for guessing, but Selangor is the other state, but only in reverse. In terms of population, Selangor has about 5.4 million people, or 19.6% of the total population. But in terms of seats allocated, it has a meagre 22 seats, or 9.9% of the total.

It doesn't take a genius to figure out that each vote in Selangor only has roughly half the power, whereas each vote in Sarawak has more than 1.5 times the power. Needless to say, despite Pakatan's overwhelming support in Selangor, it only has half the effect of what it should. And in Sarawak where BN swept almost clean in 2008, the effect is more than 1.5 times.

For those of you who are curious, the proportion of seats in all the other states roughly correspond to their respective population. Due to the skewed proportion of allocated seats, I started dreaming about an election where seats are allocated to correspond with their respective population size. So, I decided to take a look at the results if seats were allocated in that way to see if the results would have changed.

Even in my dreams, the outcome appears to remain relatively unchanged - see Chart 2.

Chart 2: Possible election results with seats allocated based according to population
I made the assumption that the proportion of seats won would remain the same. Of course, in this case, the margin that BN won by was a lot narrower. Instead of winning 140 seats against Pakatan's 82, BN would have won 128 seats against Pakatan's 95. Still a relatively wide margin. So that was the end of a fruitless dream.

Back to reality. So the next obvious question was, what would it take for Pakatan to win the next elections? Even if the number of seats were fairly allocated, Pakatan would not stand a chance if they still got killed in BN's fixed deposit states of Sarawak, Johor and Sabah.

So how many seats does Pakatan have to win in those three states if they wish to form the federal government? I started experimenting with Pakatan winning an additional 33% of seats in Sarawak, Johor and Sabah. Why 33%? No reason. Just arbitrary. Guess what?

Chart 3: What if Pakatan won an additional 33% in Sarawak, Johor and Sabah?
Now, things look pretty balanced. And indeed they are. In this case, Pakatan would win by the narrowest of margins. 112 to 110. The breakdown would be such that Pakatan would win 11 seats in Sarawak, 9 seats in Johor and 9 seats in Sabah. Nonetheless, I think this would be a disastrous result. If such a result actually transpires, it will start raining frogs. Members from both sides of the political divide would start hopping left, right and center. We probably wouldn't even know who would be the legitimate government two or three months after the elections.

Nonetheless, this is the bare minimum case in order for Pakatan to win. So, I started taking a closer look to see what it would really take for Pakatan to get that extra 33% that it needs. Table 1 shows the percentage of majority won for each seat in Sarawak. I am going to make the assumption that there will be only two parties running for each contested seat. This is not necessarily the case due to independent candidates. Based on this assumption, whatever vote that does not go to Pakatan, will go to BN and vice versa. This means that a 1% gain by Pakatan will result in a 1% loss by BN as well.

Now we are ready to test the assumptions. Assuming that since the last election 10% of the voters of BN have decided to switch over to Pakatan in this coming election. This would result in a 20 percentage point swing. Consequently, BN seats with fewer than 20% majority would swing to Pakatan's favour. This means that the eight seats highlighted in blue would swing over to Pakatan. This is short of the 11 that Pakatan needs.

Table 1: Sarawak Elections sorted by % majority
Moving on the Johor - see Table 2. With the same assumptions, Pakatan would gain a further 6 seats, ending up with 7 seats, a little shy of the 9 that is needed. If you notice, Pakatan won the Bakri seat by the narrowest of margins in 2008.

Table 2: Johor Elections sorted by % majority
Now, let's take a look at Sabah - see Table 3. With a 10% swing, only 5 seats would change hands, giving Pakatan a total of 6 seats, quite a distance from the elusive 9. Once again, the seat that was won by Pakatan was again by the narrowest of margins. Who is to say that they may not lose the seat in the coming elections?

Table 3: Sabah Elections sorted by % majority
The above analysis of course assumes that there are totally no changes in all the other states. This is quite unlikely. But I really have no idea how each and every state would vote and I am just simply going to assume that there were no changes.

Hence, based on the analysis above, Pakatan has a Herculean task ahead of them. It isn't even sufficient if it gets a 10% swing in the highlighted seats above. Even if it does get the minimal number of seats that it needs in those three states, the frog party that ensues would be catastrophic.

If I were Pakatan, I would start targeting the seats that would have the most impact. For starters, it would be those highlighted ones. After that, those that are slightly above the highlighted ones. Pakatan needs at least a 15% swing in order to even stand a chance of forming the next Federal Government.

It appears that there is still a lot of work to be done. Nonetheless, the results are not entirely disheartening. We all noticed the political tsunami that happened in March 2008. With the winds of change blowing right behind, Pakatan might just get the push that it needs. There is simply no room to rest upon its laurels, if it has any to begin with.

NB: I did not update the election results with the 16 by-elections that has happened since the 2008 elections. The analysis above is for illustration purposes only.

Saturday, May 12, 2012

The Star - Malaysia's Best Newspaper?

I am appalled to see the kind of investigative reporting that the reporters at the Star are doing. In this article today, the Star reports that 100,000 people showed their unwavering support for UMNO:

If the reporters at the Star had an ounce of initiative, they would have obtained this picture, which was shown in the Malaysian Insider:


The stadium does not even look like it is half full. And any donkey with the ability to use Google or Wikipedia will be able to find out that the Bukit Jalil stadium has a capacity of 100,000. According to Wikipedia, the seating room is about 87,000. So, with my advanced mathematics skills, I calculated half of 100,000 to be only 50,000. How did the Star come up with the 100,000 number? Who knows... Maybe it saw fit to exaggerate the amount of support for its "masters".

The Malaysian Insider portrays a more accurate picture:
KUALA LUMPUR, May 11 — Datuk Seri Najib Razak rallied Umno tonight to defend the country from being destroyed by the opposition, which he called uncivilised, undemocratic and lacking credibility.

The Umno president told at least 50,000 in the arena and thousands more loitering outside “not to let our children and grandchildren become destitute (terbangsat).”
Why is anyone still reading the Star?

Wednesday, April 27, 2011

Who is "Stupider"?

I can't help but wonder if something is amiss in this situation.

On one end, it is easy for the people to be angry that the government (SUPP) allegedly offered RM500 to buy the votes of the Iban people but if we pause for a moment and think about it, why do the Iban people fall for the same cheap tricks again and again? Is it really so easy to buy their votes? How does RM500 even come close to be able to compensate them for the "pain and suffering" that they would have to go through?

Something feels wrong here because I would not throw away my dignity for RM500. Something tells me that the Iban people won't feel inclined to do it as well. But then again, who knows?

Sunday, April 17, 2011

Volume 3 Issue 16: Two-Cent Economics

Sarawak Elections

Just some quick mathematics on today's Sarawak elections. 71 seats are up for grabs in Sarawak out of 222. The voter turnout was about 672,000. Based on the last elections in March 2008, the total number of people who voted in the whole of Malaysia was about 11 million. So, the proportion of voters who voted in Sarawak is about 6% - see Chart 1.

Chart 1: Proportion of Sarawak voters to total voters in Malaysia

Yet, the number of seats that are represented by Sarawak is 32% - see Chart 2.

Chart 2: Proportion of Parliament seats allocated to Sarawak

Does anyone else see a problem with that? Is it not fishy to have 6% of the people in Malaysia determine 32% of the country's leaders? Furthermore, the government added three seats to Sarawak in the 2008 elections, as if it were not imbalanced enough. If the government wins two-thirds majority again in this coming elections, it is almost guaranteed that more gerrymandering will happen. What say you, Malaysia?