Showing posts with label Malaysia Boleh. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Malaysia Boleh. Show all posts

Friday, June 29, 2012

Malaysia's Billionaire Crony Problem?

Volume 4 Issue 27: Intelligent Investing

The chart below is appalling, though I must say, not entirely surprising (HT: Ezra Klein). The circles on the left measure the total net worth of billionaires (in USD) and the proportion of the net worth compared with each country's GDP. 

Before the economist in you starts griping about how meaningless it is to compare the ratio of a stock variable (net worth) with that of a flow variable (GDP), let me just preemptively stop you. While on its own, it doesn't mean much, but it is possible to use it as a relative measure, as in this case. To give you examples of such ratios, in the world of speculation, analysts discuss concepts like the "PE ratio", which is the ratio of  price (a stock variable) over net income (a flow variable). Again, on its own it means nothing. But it is often used as a relative measure to compare what the market's expectation of earnings of various companies. 

But in this case, the proportion of total billionaire's net worth compared with the country's GDP just measures how concentrated wealth is among the richest bunch in the country. It is no surprise that Russia tops the list at 20.0% with all its oil tycoons and oligarchs. 

Surprise, surprise, Malaysia is No. 2 on this list! Malaysia only has NINE (actually supposed to be TEN, but   I am not exactly sure when the net worth was measured because Vincent Tan comes in 10th with a net worth of USD1.2 billion. It also depends on the methodology and exchange rate and what not). So, with just nine billionaires, the net worth of these nine people forms about 18.3% of Malaysia's GDP, not very far from Russia. The subsequent countries are far behind. What this shows is that Malaysia's wealth is heavily concentrated among these nine or ten people.   


So, who are these nine or ten people? See the list below. I am sure they are no strangers to you.


Rank Name Net Worth (USD billions)
1 Robert Kuok 12.4
2 Ananda Krishnan 9.9
3 Lee Kim Hua 6.5
4 Lee Shin Cheng 5.2
5 Teh Hong Piow 5.0
6 Quek Leng Chan 4.2
7 Syed Mokhtar Al-Bukhary 3.3
8 Yeoh Tiong Lay 2.6
9 Tiong Hiew King 1.5
10 Vincent Tan 1.2


Out of the ten names above, how many of them are cronies? I am not going name any names, but this just goes on to show how cronyism has concentrated the wealth among a few of Mahathir's good friends. In fact, this is just a small piece of a bigger puzzle. Income inequality has been rising rapidly over the past three decades, which is evidence of the utter failure of the NEP. This issue is very well-documented at Economics Malaysia. Granted, it is relatively wonkish, and definitely not for the faint-hearted. Hisham has shown that income inequality is not just a phenomenon that is apparent across ethnic groups, but it is also just as pronounced within each ethnic group itself.

Source: Economics Malaysia
The Gini coefficient measures income inequality, where 0 indicates perfect equality and 1 indicates perfect inequality. The chart above shows that income inequality has not improved since the late 1980s. In fact, it is on sort of a downward trend since around 2003.

The mega projects under the ETP would only serve to enrich a few and lead to even more inequality. Trickle-down economics is just exactly as its name suggests. The lower to middle income earners will only enjoy the scraps from the tables of those that have been awarded those mega projects. Mere trickles from a waterfall of fortune.

Wednesday, June 27, 2012

Does Increasing Traffic Fines Make Sense?

So, the geniuses up there have concocted another brilliant plan to "reduce traffic accidents". Anyone with common sense can see so many things that can go wrong with increasing the traffic fines to RM2,000.

1. Unpaid summons

As of March 2011, there were still 17 million traffic summons left unpaid. What makes the government think that people will pay up if the traffic summons were increased? Aren't they just going to offer discounts all over again?

2. More incentive for bribery

At a fine of RM300, most people would pay about RM50 in "duit kopi (coffee money)" to avoid being fined according to anecdotal evidence. Assuming the proportions are unchanged, the police would now be able to "extort" about RM300 (slightly less than a sixth of RM2,000) in bribes. Otherwise, traffic offenders would risk being fined RM2,000.

2a. Bribery redux

A suggestion made by one of my friends was to legalize duit kopi for traffic offences so that the police will work harder to apprehend traffic offenders. My first impression is that this would not work simply because the police would start working "too hard" in apprehending traffic offenders. How can working too hard be a bad thing? Well, for the simple reason that all police officers will start wanting to become traffic police. Since being a traffic police would turn into a more lucrative profession because they are now allowed to openly collect duit kopi. Who would want the dangerous task of chasing after robbers and murderers when one can easily stop a traffic offender and collect free rent? This would be an epic fail.

I don't want to be accused of just being a whiner without proposing any solutions to the problem. But herein lies the BIG question. What is the real problem? Why do people commit traffic offences? I can see two main reasons. 

First, driver's education. On the surface, the technical driving skills are relatively easy to master. Most people would have no trouble learning how to drive and park, granted there are several exceptions. But the real education is in driving temperament. Queue-cutting, lane-changing without signalling, driving on emergency lanes, tail-gating are all rampant in Malaysia. Why are people in such a rush in Malaysia? Rather, why are people so impatient to get to their destination? Will five to ten minutes delay make so much difference that it is worth risking your own and other people's lives? We always tend to believe that it will never be us when it comes to accidents, until it actually is. Let's just say that the chance of being in a serious accident is 1/1,000 for a reckless driver. On the surface, that seems like a fairly small percentage. But if you think about it, if you drive on a daily basis, you are very likely to encounter at least ONE serious accident in three years. Over a driving lifespan of 30 years (assuming you survive that long), you would have encountered at least TEN serious accidents. Do you really think you can survive?

They make us sit through one whole day of "undang" but none of this is ever mentioned. Yes, I paid attention. The Ministry seriously needs to take a look at driver's education.

Secondly, overcrowded-ness. This is a long-standing problem in Malaysia. It is simple mathematics. The more cars you have on the road, the more likely it is for accidents to happen. The problem of too many cars arise from other issues such as poor public transport, subsidized petrol, and the "Malaysia Boleh" spirit in the form of Proton. I could probably write a short book if I delve into that, but I shall refrain today.

So what are the solutions? As the first problem suggests, we seriously need to reform driver's education. While the statistics are not meant to scare, it is useful to raise awareness on the actual risks that driver's are taking compared with the minuscule benefits that they stand to gain by driving recklessly. Of course, there are many other issues that must be addressed to train a driver's temperament and this cannot be tackled without proper study.

Now, assuming that the driver's education have been reformed, the penalty for repeating traffic offenders would be to go through the new driver's education system. While we are punishing traffic offenders, might as well ensure that we educate them appropriately so that they do not repeat their offences.

Also, if we are working on increasing the fines, I propose fines that are proportionate to a person's income/wealth. Switzerland practices this. In 2010, a Swedish millionaire was fined USD1 million for driving at 290 km/h, which was 170 km/h above the limit. This should be a serious deterrent for those who are driving fast cars and attempt to tail-gate everyone along the highway.

Of course, finally, all rules are only useful if they are properly enforced. All the proposals above do not work if the police officers do not stop taking bribes. This has to be tackled on the police force's end. The recruitment has to be improved. Malaysia needs to recruit police officers that are competent and reward them accordingly. Ridiculously harsh public qualifying exams need to be implemented and those that have passed the exam will be allowed a significant pay increment to reward their efforts accordingly. In short, meritocracy must be the word of the day, and rent-seeking must be eliminated. This is easier said than done, but admitting the rampant existence of such a problem is a first step. As long as the police force continues to live in denial of their incompetency, there is no hope for change.

Monday, June 25, 2012

Malaysia's Middle Income Trap

Volume 4 Issue 26: Intelligent Investing

There are many Malaysians who are in denial and strongly believe that Malaysia is not in a middle income trap. One of the foremost arguments put across is that Malaysia is still in the factor accumulation stage of economic growth. What this means in layman's terms is that, Malaysia is still in a developing stage that relies on investment expenditure in terms of machinery and infrastructure to generate growth.
(Wonkish note on Long-Term Economic Growth:  
Conventional economic theory suggests that long-term economic growth is based on four key ingredients: natural resources, capital stock, labor and productivity. First and foremost, it is reasonable to assume that the supply of natural resources are fixed for any particular country. There is only so much land you can plant on, so much oil you can drill, and so much coal you can mine. So, you can't really generate economic growth by increasing the supply of natural resources. That is fixed.  
Secondly, capital stock is the amount of fixed assets in the economy. This includes machinery and infrastructure. Typically, in countries undergoing industrialization, a lot of the economic growth comes from investment in capital stock, which is used for manufacturing, which transforms and adds value to raw materials, and subsequently translates to income growth.  
Thirdly, of course, every economy needs a functioning labor force to grow. As long as you have the raw materials, machinery and land, you can always produce more goods by hiring more people. However, you can only hire so many people in an economy. Also, there is a certain point where you will hit diminishing marginal returns, but I will not get into that today.  
Last, and most importantly, productivity. This is the most crucial ingredient for the sustainability of long-term economic growth. The gist of productivity is basically this: "How to produce more, with less?". You can achieve long-term economic growth by finding new ways to produce more goods with less input. This is in fact, the only way, because inputs are always scarce and limited.  
End of wonkish note)
The trouble with this argument is that we have been "developing" for more than 50 years. How long should one country be developing before it becomes of developed status? The figure below is obtained courtesy of the Economist. 


The graph measures a country's GDP per capita relative to the US after accounting for purchasing power. The World Bank report done in collaboration with China's Development Research Center, China 2030, defines a high income country as those having at least 43% of the US's GDP per capita. Since the chart is in log-income terms, the high-income barrier is marked by the 3.76 lines (log 43).

If a country is rated below 3.76 on the horizontal axis, that means that in 1960, it had not achieved high income status yet. But if it had exceeded 3.76 on the vertical axis, that means that it had already achieved high income status in 2008.

Countries in the top right box are those that were already high income in 1960, and have stayed there in 2008. Note that Malaysia is in the middle box labelled "Middle-Income Trap". This means that Malaysia was already a middle-income country in 1960, and had failed to escape the middle-income status even after 48 years of developing. Of course, this box is the most highly populated, clearly showing that Malaysia is not alone in being stuck in the middle-income trap.

This is no reason for us to give a pat on the back to ourselves and say "It's OK". It is NOT OK. We need to escape this mentality that it is OK because other people have failed too. In fact, I would argue that this is an even bigger reason to worry. So many others have tried and failed. Clearly achieving high income status is not as easily achievable as those illustrated in Idris Jala's pretty charts.

Ideally, we would like to be in the middle-top box, labelled "Middle-Income to High Income". This box represents countries that have been able to move from middle to high-income status and count countries like South Korea, Taiwan, and most definitely Singapore, even though it was not labelled on the chart.

It is time to stop relying on capital accumulation. Malaysia does not need taller buildings, longer roads, bigger computers and what not. Malaysia needs to focus on productivity. Malaysians need to work harder and smarter, so that we can start producing more goods with less input. And this can only happen if we stop subsidizing the cronies and stop rewarding rent-seekers with mega-projects. The culture of meritocracy must also be ingrained so that effort is justly rewarded. Otherwise, how can we produce more with less when lazy buggers are allowed to piggy-back on the hard work of others?

This is what the Economic Transformation Programme should focus on. Not the myriad of capital accumulation projects that Idris Jala can't stop talking about.

Borrowing iPads in Singaporean Libraries

You can now borrow iPads, Kindles and such from Singaporean libraries:
Apart from borrowing books and DVDs, the public can now get their hands on iPads, TumbleBooks Playaways and Kindles as part of the National Library Board's (NLB) efforts to help bridge the digital divide among Singaporeans.
One hundred TumbleBooks Playaways, 100 iPads and five Kindles will be available for loan from today at Bedok Public Library.
In Malaysia, you still can't even borrow a decent book from the national libraries. Of course this is slightly exaggerating, but this is a serious handicap in Malaysia. Books are expensive. In the last two months, I have spent over RM300 on books and I already feel the burn in my pockets. Libraries are important to enable accessibility to books that some people may not be able to afford.


Central Public Library, Singapore

In this respect, Singapore is centuries ahead of Malaysia. Just look at this multi-storey national library in Bugis. This is just one of the many, many libraries in Singapore. Singapore has at least 24 public libraries to cater to its population of five million people. I shudder to think how many functional public libraries Malaysia has. 


I used to volunteer at public libraries in Singapore and despite going there almost on a weekly basis, I continued to be amazed by how many interesting books there are and how easy it is to get a book that you want in any library there. This may be a bit bonus to a Singaporean, but I was rather impressed with the fact that you could request for a book to be delivered from another library to the library that is closest to your home so that you can borrow it at your convenience. You don't have to travel all the way across town just to get a book that is only available there. 


And now, they have iPads that are pre-loaded with 2.2 million ebooks. I don't even think Malaysian libraries have 2.2 million books. 



Wednesday, May 16, 2012

Volume 4 Issue 18: Intelligent Investing

Burma's Turn. When Is It Malaysia's Turn?

I kept this article from quite a while back but didn't manage to write anything meaningful about it. Nonetheless, it is a Stiglitz piece, and it would be a shame if I did not share it. Stiglitz talks about Burma (or now known as Myanmar) and its prospects after the leadership change which brought forth a string of rapid reform measures that makes Najib's reform measures look bad. Here is some extract:
Under the leadership of the new president, Thein Sein, the authorities have responded to calls for a political and economic opening. Progress has been made on peace agreements with ethnic-minority insurgents – conflicts rooted in the divide-and-rule strategy of colonialism, which the country’s post-independence rulers maintained for more than six decades. The Nobel laureate Daw Aung San Suu Kyi was not only released from house arrest, but is now campaigning hard for a parliamentary seat in April’s by-elections. 
On the economic front, unprecedented transparency has been introduced into the budgetary process. Expenditures on health care and education have been doubled, albeit from a low base. Licensing restrictions in a number of key areas have been loosened. The government has even committed itself to moving towards unifying its complicated exchange-rate system. 
The spirit of hope in the country is palpable, though some older people, who saw earlier moments of apparent relaxation of authoritarian rule come and go, remain cautious. Perhaps that is why some in the international community are similarly hesitant about easing Myanmar’s isolation. But most Burmese sense that if changes are managed well, the country will have embarked on an irreversible course.
I think the question that is so mind-boggling is, if countries like Myanmar and Senegal can do it, what is stopping Malaysia from implementing meaningful reforms? Are we so short of ideas? You know it is worrying when your Prime Minister has to set up a website to seek ideas on how to improve the country.

Saturday, May 12, 2012

The Star - Malaysia's Best Newspaper?

I am appalled to see the kind of investigative reporting that the reporters at the Star are doing. In this article today, the Star reports that 100,000 people showed their unwavering support for UMNO:

If the reporters at the Star had an ounce of initiative, they would have obtained this picture, which was shown in the Malaysian Insider:


The stadium does not even look like it is half full. And any donkey with the ability to use Google or Wikipedia will be able to find out that the Bukit Jalil stadium has a capacity of 100,000. According to Wikipedia, the seating room is about 87,000. So, with my advanced mathematics skills, I calculated half of 100,000 to be only 50,000. How did the Star come up with the 100,000 number? Who knows... Maybe it saw fit to exaggerate the amount of support for its "masters".

The Malaysian Insider portrays a more accurate picture:
KUALA LUMPUR, May 11 — Datuk Seri Najib Razak rallied Umno tonight to defend the country from being destroyed by the opposition, which he called uncivilised, undemocratic and lacking credibility.

The Umno president told at least 50,000 in the arena and thousands more loitering outside “not to let our children and grandchildren become destitute (terbangsat).”
Why is anyone still reading the Star?

Saturday, April 07, 2012

Volume 4 Issue 14: Intelligent Investing

The Malaysian Delusion

It's very difficult to be a Malaysian. One of the reasons is that, very often, we get compared with Singaporeans and are told how well they are doing. I mean, I am one of those people who probably compares Malaysia with Singapore a bit too much.

Very often, people point out that Malaysia is a much larger country compared with Singapore, which is why it is more difficult to manage. Singapore has a much smaller population, so it has less mouths to feed. That's why people there are richer. This is all a bunch of hogwash. 

Let us consider a very simple example. Korea has a population of about 49 million people, about 1.75 times that of Malaysia. It also has a much smaller land area (about 100,000 square km) compared with Malaysia's abundant land space (about 330,000 square km). This also means that Malaysia has more resources and space to grow. Malaysia is also not located next to North Korea, which boasts all sorts of nuclear weapons which can be seen as all kinds of threats to its sovereignty. 

But look at the economic performance of Korea in the last 30 years or so. Korea's GDP per capita was almost at par with that of Malaysia in 1980, but is now almost triple that of Malaysia - see chart 1.

Chart 1
And here we have our Bank Negara Annual Report (White Box - pdf) claiming that the Malaysian economy is doing well as it has managed to diversify further by relying less on manufacturing. This is ridiculous because Korea has an even larger dependence on manufacturing compared with Malaysia - see chart 2.

Chart 2
The real weakness is that Malaysia is becoming less and less competitive and is no longer able to attract low-end manufacturers as wages in Malaysia have kept on increasing without commensurate increase in productivity. Furthermore, it does not have enough skilled workers to attract high-end manufacturers. One of the most impressive achievements that Korea has made over the past 30 years is the little known fact (maybe it is just my ignorance) that Koreans have focused strongly on education. In chart 3 (source: OECD), we can see that more than 60% of young Koreans (25-34 year-olds) have attained tertiary education. This is in contrast with the older generation of Koreans (55-64 year-olds) whereby less than 15% have attained tertiary education.

Chart 3
The improvement is nothing short of tremendous. It is by far the best among all OECD countries. What is interesting to note is that the US actually went in reverse, recording a lower proportion of young people with tertiary education compared with the older generation.

This is one of the core factors that allow high-end manufacturing the thrive in Korea. Of course, in Malaysia, the amount of people with tertiary education has surged, but what kind of graduates are we getting? As Tony Pua wrote in his book, "The Tiger That Lost Its Roar", Malaysia has 20 public universities, 24 private universities and 21 "university colleges" to serve its "small" population of 28 million. That translates to about 430,000 people per university. In comparison, Singapore, which has about 5 million people, has only three universities. This translates to about 1.7 million people per university.

Sadly, the quantity of universities say nothing about the quality of Malaysian graduates. The quality of some of the universities are so bad that the graduates are deemed unfit to enter the workforce. So why is the Deputy Prime Minister still in denial about the poor quality of our education system?

In short, this myth about Singapore being an easier country to manage is just nonsense. Even a much more populated country like Korea which lacks the natural resources that Malaysia has can transform itself into a high income economy. The important lesson here is that in order to improve, we have to stop living in denial and start looking for where we went wrong. 


Wednesday, April 04, 2012

Wasting Taxpayers Money - The American Way

I don't know if the US had taken a play out of the ol' Malaysian playbook, but when I read this, I can't help but stifle a chuckle as I reminisce about how rampant such occurrences are in Malaysia:
The chief of the General Services Administration resigned, two of her top deputies were fired and four managers were placed on leave Monday amid reports of lavish spending at a conference off the Las Vegas Strip that featured a clown, a mind reader and a $31,208 reception. 
Administrator Martha N. Johnson, in her resignation letter, acknowledged a “significant misstep” at the agency that manages real estate for the federal government. “Taxpayer dollars were squandered,” she wrote. At the start of her tenure in February 2010 she called ethics “a big issue for me.” 
... 
The leadership collapse came hours before GSA Inspector General Brian D. Miller released a scathing report on the $823,000 training conference, held for 300 West Coast employees at the M Resort and Casino, an opulent hotel in Henderson, Nev., just south of Las Vegas. From $130,000 in travel expenses for six scouting trips to a $2,000 party in Peck’s loft suite, event planners violated federal limits on conference spending.
And in Malaysia, we have submarines that do not submerge, RM42,000 laptops and what not. The trouble with this is that, in Malaysia, no one ever gets fired. As I have proposed before, the easiest way to go about this is to fire the person whose signature is on the check. It is his job to check that all the payments are legitimate before it is paid out. If the check has Najib's signature, then it is even more worrying. He should immediately step down for failing the Malaysian people.

This is exactly what happens in the US. Accountability is key and it has to begin from the top. The people in high places with authority need to step up and take responsibility. It is useless to deny that there are any problems. As Lim Guan Eng has cleverly put it, if you keep denying any problem exists, then you won't be looking for solutions. It is as simple as that.

Tuesday, March 06, 2012

More Brain Drain

I don't think I need to say much more about this as it is common knowledge by now. This is just another classic example of the effects of brain drain in Malaysia:
Malaysia-born Ren Ng is revolutionising photography with his Lytro light-field camera.

The Australian has developed a new technology for the mass market that allows anyone to adjust the focal point of digital photographs after they have been taken, and without having to fiddle with Photoshop or other image-editing tools. 
The hand-sized digital point-and-shot camera looks like a torchlight; its key feature is what the California-based company calls “shoot now, focus later”. 
In an interview with the New York Times last year, Lytro chief executive Ng described the images as “interactive, living pictures” due to their ability to be manipulated. 
The Lytro achieves this trick with a special sensor called a micro lens array, which puts the equivalent of many lenses into a small space.
The camera was listed as Time magazine’s “50 best inventions” in its November 17 edition last year. 
Ren Ng is currently an Australian. One can only wonder what made his parents migrate to Australia when he was nine.

Sunday, February 19, 2012

Volume 4 Issue 7: Intelligent Investing

Civil Service Wages - One Step Forward, Two Steps Back



Another way to put this is that the government is not only shooting itself in the foot. It is also shooting Malaysia in the face. 

In the guise of "raising" public sector wages, the government had once again served the interests of the people in the top echelons of public service:
The Malaysian Insider understands that Putrajaya wants to completely overhaul the scheme which only seemed to benefit top civil servants but many of an estimated 2,000 senior civil servants have already signed and consented to the new scheme, which guarantees a pay rise of some RM5,000 a month.
Can you believe that some of the civil servants are guaranteed a pay rise of RM5,000 per month? The increase alone is more than most of our monthly incomes. Get this:
The proposal, which sees the highest pay at RM60,000 a month for the Chief Secretary to the Government while those in lower pay grades would receive an increment as low as RM1.70, has ignited anger and disapproval in the 1.4 million-strong civil service — a key vote bank for the ruling Barisan Nasional (BN) coalition — ahead of a general election that must be called by May 2013.
 I don't know how RM1.70 is going to make any difference in a person's life. Clearly the plan was well-thought out. So not only are the "rich" rewarded, but the poor are being marginalized yet again. As if the problem of inequality isn't bad enough.

Long ago, I had already recommended a "wage policy" that was simple and transparent:
It is now rampant that local graduates these days can barely qualify for a job at an MNC, even with the current wage level. I have been taught by graduates with engineering degrees in my secondary school. That was almost eight years ago. The situation is that bad. If you increase the minimum wages in sectors with positive externalities, you could possibly create a productivity multiplier. More people would want to be in these areas. For example, if a teacher's salary were to be increased significantly, more people would want to become teachers. Of course the buck must not stop there. The pay for the people who actually train these teachers have to increase as well. This will result in two things. First, too many people will want to become teachers. Now, this may seem like a bad thing at first. But this is the most fundamental concept of life. Just think about how you were born. Millions of sperm going after one ova. The fittest will survive. In this case, only the best people will get to be teachers. I mean, look at doctors. When you talk to parents, they stereotypically want their children to grow up to be doctors, lawyers and whatever. Why? Because it is a high paying job and not many people get to become doctors.

This competition for survival will push for the selectivity of the people who actually qualify for the profession. Even with the failed-notion of meritocracy in our country (by that, I mean, not all the best people will be selected because of our quota system) there will be an invisible force to select the better few to perform an important job function. The majority of the people who want to become teachers would be sufficiently qualified and so would their trainers.

Now, the second result is where the positive externality comes in. I pause to make an assumption here. I assert that good teachers will increase the number of good students. With more good students who eventually become useful graduates and consequently productive workers in all industries, the economy of our country will be thriving. Think first world thriving.
This proposal also signals to the general public about what jobs does the government think is important. In my opinion, doctors and teachers should come first in order to maintain long-term growth sustainability. We need to keep our population healthy, and we need to keep our population competitive intelectually.

But it goes without saying that any wage increase has to come with proportionate improvement in productivity. And to do this,  the government or the statistics department has to come up with a proper way to measure productivity and collect data on it, just like the US. As I have shared before, one of Bob Parson's 16 rules of success is:
Measure anything of significance
When you start measuring anything and everything that you deem as important, then only can you measure your improvements. If you merely wish to "improve productivity", it does not make sense if you have no way to measure productivity.

All these are just preliminary steps that need to be taken to even come close to reforming the Malaysian economy and society in its path towards high income. All we are hearing now is just lip-service and half-hearted attempts (I also wrote about them in recently, here, here and here) at appeasing the public before the impending elections.

Friday, February 10, 2012

Nursing Nurses? Outrageous!

Just a few days ago, I could not help but shake my head when I read this news:
THE latest government statistics show that in 2010, more than 54% of private nursing diploma graduates were not able to find work three to four months after graduating, compared to only 21.7% in 2008. 
In that same year, there were 37,702 students enrolled in nursing diploma courses in 61 private institutions of higher learning (IPTS). Each year, some 12,000 will exit into the marketplace but the demand for new nurses in the private sector is only about 1,500 a year. 
And if you think it is easier for them to get a job in the public sector, the Health Ministry only hired 438 of these diploma holders in 2010, as it draws its bulk of nurses from public institutions of higher learning. 
When it comes to passing the Nursing Board examination, the private sector candidates, though more in numbers, have a lower passing rate. 
The conclusion one arrives at from these statistics is that there is a gross mismatch between supply and demand. But that is not the complete picture.
Guess what the ingenious government has come up with to solve such a problem?
PUTRAJAYA: The Health Ministry is working on creating vacancies at government hospitals to absorb the large number of unemployed graduate nurses. 
Health Minister Datuk Seri Liow Tiong Lai said a special committee, led by Health director-general Datuk Seri Dr Hasan Abdul Rahman, had been set up to find a solution to the issue. 
“We are working on a programme to promote those who are already in the system and the vacancies can then be filled up by the graduates,” he said yesterday. 
Liow pointed out that the proposed programme aimed to train the current crop of nurses to specialise in one of the many fields in government hospitals and in the process, create vacancies in lower-level positions.
This basically means that you and I (at least, those of us who pay Malaysian taxes) are paying for their lack of employability. One has got to ask, why do so many people want to become nurses, when they should know that the demand for nurses is not there? Somewhere, somehow, the incentive structure has gone wrong. By no means do nurses earn a high pay. So the only possible explanation is that it is easy to obtain a nursing degree. I am not saying that it is easy to be a nurse. I am just saying that it is way too easy to get a degree in nursing.

Why? Well, the question to ask is, why don't these people want to become actuaries? I believe actuaries sure as heck earn a lot more than nurses. There is probably excess demand for actuaries compared with the supply. The question is of course, rhetorical. Graduating with a degree in actuarial science is hard.

In contrast, graduating with a nursing degree, most likely, not as difficult. So why should regular Malaysian taxpayers like you and me be paying for these people who have chosen the "easy" way out. They should have probably worked harder to get more useful and employable skills in order to earn a proper living instead of having to rely on handouts by the Ministry of Health, which are actually Malaysian taxpayers' hard earned money. This is simply another example of the shameless attitude among Malaysians that demonstrate the impracticality of the ETP in "transforming" the country. For more examples, read here and here and here and here.

This is simply an outrage!

Wednesday, February 08, 2012

Volume 4 Issue 5: Intelligent Investing

The Malaysian Disease?

As well as being right and proper, such reform makes political sense too. A younger generation of Malaysians resents the ethnic divisiveness practised by the ruling establishment and yearns for more political and social freedoms. It means that the centre ground of politics, on which the next general election will be fought, has shifted away from the politics of Malay supremacy. 
The trouble is that though Mr Najib believes in change, much of his party clearly does not. UMNO was founded specifically to protect Malay privileges and has ruled Malaysia without interruption since independence. Mr Najib came to power in 2009 not through an electoral mandate for change, but in an internal coup. As a consequence, he lacks the clout and possibly the will to impose his agenda on UMNO. And the longer he postpones an election, the more his personal authority will ebb.
...
Obstructionism from within the governing system to Mr Najib’s reforms has become brazen. Take the Peaceful Assembly Bill, awaiting signing into law. This legislation, from the attorney-general’s office, seems to go directly against much of Mr Najib’s earlier declarations about the need for greater civic freedoms. To many, the bill, regulating the right to protest, seems to be even more restrictive than what went before. Najibistas in the cabinet claim that they fought back bravely, watering down some of the more draconian provisions. Nonetheless, the new law has come in for condemnation, including by UN human-rights people. 
So much for the great reform programme. The pity of Mr Najib is that a well-intentioned man has reformed just enough to alienate his own party and too little to convince the centre ground. He may be courting electoral disaster.
Subsequently, our friendly neighborhood MCA president "took the initiative" to defend Najib:
“Everybody talked about abolishing the ISA but it was Najib who removed the ISA,” he told reporters at SMJK Chong Hwa here this afternoon. 
“And that effectively removed his authority to detain people without trial. It’s not easy for a leader to give power away like that.”
I think the obvious retort to the above example would be the implementation of the Peaceful Assembly Bill that was passed in December 2011. It is not that different from the ISA that was abolished. Anyone who has not lived under a coconut shell should know that.

But I think the Economist has hit home in the sense that the attempts are very half-baked and half-hearted. The ETP is merely window-dressing in the government's attempt to reinvigorate the "feel-good" atmosphere reminiscent of the Mahathir era. It does not solve the root causes of Malaysia's problems.

Perhaps the goal of becoming a high-income nation is high and mighty, but as every one knows, you cannot construct a tall building when your foundation is built with a deck of cards. Talent and hard work is still not being appropriately recognized in Malaysia. The belief of self-entitlement is still rampant, and is clearly exemplified in the following videos:


This is probably one of the all-time bests:


Bear in mind that these are members of parliament. They are the ones who are in charge of "law-making" in this country. And then there is also the issue of corruption. To list out the examples of reported corruption cases would be too depressing.

So, I don't care if it is the GTP, or the ETP, or the NEM, or the 10MP, or the NKEAs, or the SRIs, or the PEMANDU, or the PEMUDA, or whatever other acronyms that the government can come up with to pull a wool over the people's eyes. The government cannot just reform for the sake of wanting to reform. This is not a "sandiwara" (performance). It cannot be for show.

Reforms are meant to improve the country and its people. You cannot just throw money and people and expect them to build better lives. You cannot build a rich nation when it is still filled with lousy attitude. You cannot imagine what you see below happen in a KFC anywhere else:



It is simply appalling that a worker handling food would do such a thing without care for his fellow Malaysians who are going to eat that piece of chicken. Where is the sense of responsibility and pride in their work?

While it is not meant to be a generalization of the attitudes of all Malaysians, but it should be a worrying sign. Last year, I wrote about my visit to Ayamas and how my experience was extremely disheartening:
Walking up to the shop, I saw three of the staff who were standing at the entrance, chit-chatting away with one of their friends who brought along a baby in a stroller. They completely blocked the entrance and did not care less if a customer was trying to purchase something in the shop. After making eye contact with them, they decided to reluctantly step aside to allow me to enter to buy myself some Ayamas chicken.
...
So here I am, walking into the shop, looking forward to my "Perchik Chicken" and I saw another two employees sitting behind the counter chatting away. The first question that came to my mind was, "Why do they need 5 people working when the entire shop was empty?".

So I walked up to the counter and I asked for my Perchik Chicken and to my dismay, the staff told me that it was out of stock. Mind you that this was only 6.30 pm, which is dinner time for most people. They simply never cooked any. So after some deliberation, I decided to buy some of the original roasted chicken anyway and when I inquired about purchasing a bottle of chilli sauce that my family needed, the staff again replied with an air of arrogance that it was also out of stock.
By the way, coincidentally, or otherwise, both KFC and Ayamas are owned by the same company. Is this due to the lack of staff training? Or does it speak more about the general attitude of Malaysians these days?

I simply do not see how the ETP and whatnot can solve the social ills that is clearly seen and demonstrated in the everyday walks of life. The poor attitude descends from the high echelons of mighty politicians all the way down to food servers in the kitchens of KFCs. And as everyone knows, attitudes are hard to change and it will require a lot more self-reflection and soul-searching (which is often painful) before Malaysia can transform itself into a first world country.

Wednesday, January 04, 2012

Learning From Hungary

It may be shocking for you to know that a European country is becoming more and more like Malaysia. Read here and here. I don't think I need to add any further comments, especially when time has become an increasingly valuable commodity these days.

Source: Paul Krugman

Friday, October 28, 2011

No Pay Rise?!

I think for a lot of Malaysians, it is hard to imagine what it is like to have no pay raise for many years on end. In fact, many Malaysians have come to the assumption that salary adjustments can only mean the upward kind. This attitude is so prevalent that it is ingrained into the minds of many fresh graduates today. Pay increments are now taken for granted. In fact, people expect bonuses even without working beyond what is expected of them. It is called BONUS for a reason. BONUS is paid to people who do what is BEYOND the requirements. One of the reasons I am bringing this up is the 2010 Auditor General Report that showed many of the GLCs paying out 1-2 month bonuses despite making losses year after year. One has got to ask, what are they being rewarded for? Exceptional consistency in loss-making?

Here is what I really wanted to share


This is what the average income per person in Italy looks like in the past three decades or so. More importantly, look at the last 10 years (starting from 2000). Not only has it rarely budged from the USD34-36,000 range (in real terms), it has fallen to about USD33,000 after the recent financial crisis. Can you imagine no salary increases for 10 consecutive years? Can you imagine taking a pay cut after 8 years of no pay increases?

Remember that there is no room for poor attitude and nothing comes for free. Take nothing for granted.

HT: Marginal Revolution

Tuesday, October 18, 2011

Malaysians react like dicks to BN and pussies to PR

Some of you may remember that I linked Zewt before. Here he is again with his epicly accurate portrayals:
As Zewt As It Gets: Malaysians react like dicks to BN and pussies to PR: "It doesn’t matter how much BN has screwed up the country, but just some sweeteners… hmmm, steam already. Take the recent agreement to form some committee to review the electoral process… wah, check out the reaction in facebook… all dicks got hard. I even saw a comment saying BN has finally woken up and will reform. No need to know the details, just one announcement is enough to make you steam. See now what entailed out of it…
It doesn’t matter whether they spent MYR1.8b in a facebook page or wasted MYR12b+ in PKFZ or going to spend MYR5b on a mega structure (is this still going on?) or blew the budget in building the palace and a whole fucking long list of fucked-ups. Just announced that there will be no toll during Hari Raya… steam! Everyone happy…"


Monday, August 22, 2011

A Bridge to Somewhere (but in the wrong place)

Read here.

This is a classic case of Malaysia Boleh. Except it is not in Malaysia. The article shows that not only is it more expensive to build a longer bridge (The Tappan Zee Bridge is built across one of the widest points of the Hudson River), it is even more expensive to maintain it. The structure is deteriorating fast as it is carrying more traffic than it was designed to hold. If the bridge had been shorter, the maintenance would not have been so high. This is the kind of lack of long-term planning that Malaysia so glaringly lacks. We just build and build without proper planning and then realize (much too late) that we should have done it in other ways. We can see this in the hundreds of highways around Klang Valley. We have the NPE, NKVE, Sprint, Elite, Guthrie, Maju, LDP, Penchala Link, Seremban Highway, etc. I can't even name them all.

With so many unplanned highways, is it a wonder if we see so many potholes around Klang Valley?

Monday, August 15, 2011

No Roadblock?

While the fact that there will be no roadblocks on the highway during the holidays seems like a welcomed move, the justification given is laughable:
He said the method was first tried last year on a trial basis and many motorists were shocked and embarrassed when shown the photographs of them breaking the law.
“The hassle of having to come to JPJ offices and being interviewed over their offences was a deterrent enough for many of them,” he said when launching JPJ Hari Raya Aidilfitri Ops yesterday.
I like how these people use terms like "many" etc. so freely. I wonder if they ever collect statistics of such things. If they don't, they should. But what is funny is the bolded part. It is definitely true that having to go to the JPJ offices is more than enough to be a deterrent of committing a traffic offence. It is sad, but true. One typically has to spend about 2-3 hours at the JPJ office for an "interview", where they will just show you a picture of your car (yeah, there is no way they can prove where you really are just from the picture), and then they tell you where you committed your offence. The joke is, they would have sent you a letter inviting you in for this "interview" regarding an offence that was committed about 3-4 months ago. We won't even remember if we actually passed by that particular road 3-4 months ago.

I don't know how that proves your guilt, but the fact that you already had to wait 2 hours before the "interview" would make you feel like you should just pay the fine anyway, regardless of whether you truly committed the offence or not. It is just not worth wasting the time over it. But I digress.

The key takeaway from this is that the JPJ is actually PROUD of their inefficiency. They are so proud of it that they actually see it as a deterrent to people committing traffic offences. I don't even know where to begin to explain how wrong this is. But I guess I could begin with:
"Well, I guess they never have to improve their efficiency ever again." 


Sunday, August 14, 2011

Volume 3 Issue 33: Two-Cent Economics

Why Malaysia Still Needs Manufacturing



We can all pretend that the services industry will provide the high value-added jobs. Following this, the next logical step is probably to focus on creating a lot of jobs in the high-skilled services sectors. That way, Malaysia will transform into a high income economy.

What is wrong with that argument? Here is the article which explains why every country, not just Malaysia needs jobs in the manufacturing sector:
We may live in a post-industrial age, in which information technologies, biotech, and high-value services have become drivers of economic growth. But countries ignore the health of their manufacturing industries at their peril.
High-tech services demand specialized skills and create few jobs, so their contribution to aggregate employment is bound to remain limited. Manufacturing, on the other hand, can absorb large numbers of workers with moderate skills, providing them with stable jobs and good benefits. For most countries, therefore, it remains a potent source of high-wage employment.
Indeed, the manufacturing sector is also where the world’s middle classes take shape and grow. Without a vibrant manufacturing base, societies tend to divide between rich and poor – those who have access to steady, well-paying jobs, and those whose jobs are less secure and lives more precarious. Manufacturing may ultimately be central to the vigor of a nation’s democracy.
....
The bulk of new employment has come in “personal and social services,” which is where the economy’s least productive jobs are found. This migration of jobs down the productivity ladder has shaved 0.3 percentage points off US productivity growth every year since 1990 – roughly one-sixth of the actual gain over this period. The growing proportion of low-productivity labor has also contributed to rising inequality in American society.
The loss of US manufacturing jobs accelerated after 2000, with global competition the likely culprit. As Maggie McMillan of the International Food Policy Research Institute has shown, there is an uncanny negative correlation across individual manufacturing industries between employment changes in China and the US. Where China has expanded the most, the US has lost the greatest number of jobs. In the few industries that contracted in China, the US has gained employment.
....
As economies develop and become richer, manufacturing – “making things” – inevitably becomes less important. But if this happens more rapidly than workers can acquire advanced skills, the result can be a dangerous imbalance between an economy’s productive structure and its workforce. We can see the consequences all over the world, in the form of economic underperformance, widening inequality, and divisive politics.


Monday, July 18, 2011

Malaysia Sending Maids to Indonesia?

While it would seem absurd to some of you when I suggest this at this point, I don't think it's that completely far-fetched. I have brought this up with some of you, and many of you take this as a joke. Maybe, maybe not.

But read here. Does it really seem so absurd after all? Or is it something that we just shudder to think about?

Here is an excerpt:
In a commentary by the Jakarta Post on July 11, it said Malaysian leaders were laboring under an old paradigm that said a nation could have either development or democracy, but not both. “The lengths the government went to in trying to prevent and then break up the Bersih 2.0 rally in Kuala Lumpur on Saturday shows that the nation’s leaders were still not prepared to let go — even when an increasing number of Malaysians of all races have been pressing for more freedom and justice.
“We have news for them: You can be rich and free at the same time,” the editorial wrote.
Adnan was quoted as having said that the Malaysian government feared that visits to the country by Indonesians might fall if the former did not provide full explanations to the latter, citing Indonesia’s importance to Malaysia’a economy.
Indonesia is after all, one of Southeast Asia’s sexiest economies currently, and is dubbed as the “New China” in this region, thanks to its booming middle-class and young population. Indonesian workers also play a prominent role in Malaysia’s economy, especially in labor-intensive sectors. Equally important are Malaysian businesses in Indonesia, which range from the financial services to the plantation and mining sectors.
No doubt, economics is a trump card for Indonesia to wield its influence on Malaysia. By 2015, Indonesia’s economy is expected to account for half of the Association of Southeast Asia Nations’ (ASEAN) gross domestic product (GDP). That makes Indonesia the member country to lead the region.