Showing posts with label Economics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Economics. Show all posts

Friday, June 29, 2012

Malaysia's Billionaire Crony Problem?

Volume 4 Issue 27: Intelligent Investing

The chart below is appalling, though I must say, not entirely surprising (HT: Ezra Klein). The circles on the left measure the total net worth of billionaires (in USD) and the proportion of the net worth compared with each country's GDP. 

Before the economist in you starts griping about how meaningless it is to compare the ratio of a stock variable (net worth) with that of a flow variable (GDP), let me just preemptively stop you. While on its own, it doesn't mean much, but it is possible to use it as a relative measure, as in this case. To give you examples of such ratios, in the world of speculation, analysts discuss concepts like the "PE ratio", which is the ratio of  price (a stock variable) over net income (a flow variable). Again, on its own it means nothing. But it is often used as a relative measure to compare what the market's expectation of earnings of various companies. 

But in this case, the proportion of total billionaire's net worth compared with the country's GDP just measures how concentrated wealth is among the richest bunch in the country. It is no surprise that Russia tops the list at 20.0% with all its oil tycoons and oligarchs. 

Surprise, surprise, Malaysia is No. 2 on this list! Malaysia only has NINE (actually supposed to be TEN, but   I am not exactly sure when the net worth was measured because Vincent Tan comes in 10th with a net worth of USD1.2 billion. It also depends on the methodology and exchange rate and what not). So, with just nine billionaires, the net worth of these nine people forms about 18.3% of Malaysia's GDP, not very far from Russia. The subsequent countries are far behind. What this shows is that Malaysia's wealth is heavily concentrated among these nine or ten people.   


So, who are these nine or ten people? See the list below. I am sure they are no strangers to you.


Rank Name Net Worth (USD billions)
1 Robert Kuok 12.4
2 Ananda Krishnan 9.9
3 Lee Kim Hua 6.5
4 Lee Shin Cheng 5.2
5 Teh Hong Piow 5.0
6 Quek Leng Chan 4.2
7 Syed Mokhtar Al-Bukhary 3.3
8 Yeoh Tiong Lay 2.6
9 Tiong Hiew King 1.5
10 Vincent Tan 1.2


Out of the ten names above, how many of them are cronies? I am not going name any names, but this just goes on to show how cronyism has concentrated the wealth among a few of Mahathir's good friends. In fact, this is just a small piece of a bigger puzzle. Income inequality has been rising rapidly over the past three decades, which is evidence of the utter failure of the NEP. This issue is very well-documented at Economics Malaysia. Granted, it is relatively wonkish, and definitely not for the faint-hearted. Hisham has shown that income inequality is not just a phenomenon that is apparent across ethnic groups, but it is also just as pronounced within each ethnic group itself.

Source: Economics Malaysia
The Gini coefficient measures income inequality, where 0 indicates perfect equality and 1 indicates perfect inequality. The chart above shows that income inequality has not improved since the late 1980s. In fact, it is on sort of a downward trend since around 2003.

The mega projects under the ETP would only serve to enrich a few and lead to even more inequality. Trickle-down economics is just exactly as its name suggests. The lower to middle income earners will only enjoy the scraps from the tables of those that have been awarded those mega projects. Mere trickles from a waterfall of fortune.

Monday, June 25, 2012

Malaysia's Middle Income Trap

Volume 4 Issue 26: Intelligent Investing

There are many Malaysians who are in denial and strongly believe that Malaysia is not in a middle income trap. One of the foremost arguments put across is that Malaysia is still in the factor accumulation stage of economic growth. What this means in layman's terms is that, Malaysia is still in a developing stage that relies on investment expenditure in terms of machinery and infrastructure to generate growth.
(Wonkish note on Long-Term Economic Growth:  
Conventional economic theory suggests that long-term economic growth is based on four key ingredients: natural resources, capital stock, labor and productivity. First and foremost, it is reasonable to assume that the supply of natural resources are fixed for any particular country. There is only so much land you can plant on, so much oil you can drill, and so much coal you can mine. So, you can't really generate economic growth by increasing the supply of natural resources. That is fixed.  
Secondly, capital stock is the amount of fixed assets in the economy. This includes machinery and infrastructure. Typically, in countries undergoing industrialization, a lot of the economic growth comes from investment in capital stock, which is used for manufacturing, which transforms and adds value to raw materials, and subsequently translates to income growth.  
Thirdly, of course, every economy needs a functioning labor force to grow. As long as you have the raw materials, machinery and land, you can always produce more goods by hiring more people. However, you can only hire so many people in an economy. Also, there is a certain point where you will hit diminishing marginal returns, but I will not get into that today.  
Last, and most importantly, productivity. This is the most crucial ingredient for the sustainability of long-term economic growth. The gist of productivity is basically this: "How to produce more, with less?". You can achieve long-term economic growth by finding new ways to produce more goods with less input. This is in fact, the only way, because inputs are always scarce and limited.  
End of wonkish note)
The trouble with this argument is that we have been "developing" for more than 50 years. How long should one country be developing before it becomes of developed status? The figure below is obtained courtesy of the Economist. 


The graph measures a country's GDP per capita relative to the US after accounting for purchasing power. The World Bank report done in collaboration with China's Development Research Center, China 2030, defines a high income country as those having at least 43% of the US's GDP per capita. Since the chart is in log-income terms, the high-income barrier is marked by the 3.76 lines (log 43).

If a country is rated below 3.76 on the horizontal axis, that means that in 1960, it had not achieved high income status yet. But if it had exceeded 3.76 on the vertical axis, that means that it had already achieved high income status in 2008.

Countries in the top right box are those that were already high income in 1960, and have stayed there in 2008. Note that Malaysia is in the middle box labelled "Middle-Income Trap". This means that Malaysia was already a middle-income country in 1960, and had failed to escape the middle-income status even after 48 years of developing. Of course, this box is the most highly populated, clearly showing that Malaysia is not alone in being stuck in the middle-income trap.

This is no reason for us to give a pat on the back to ourselves and say "It's OK". It is NOT OK. We need to escape this mentality that it is OK because other people have failed too. In fact, I would argue that this is an even bigger reason to worry. So many others have tried and failed. Clearly achieving high income status is not as easily achievable as those illustrated in Idris Jala's pretty charts.

Ideally, we would like to be in the middle-top box, labelled "Middle-Income to High Income". This box represents countries that have been able to move from middle to high-income status and count countries like South Korea, Taiwan, and most definitely Singapore, even though it was not labelled on the chart.

It is time to stop relying on capital accumulation. Malaysia does not need taller buildings, longer roads, bigger computers and what not. Malaysia needs to focus on productivity. Malaysians need to work harder and smarter, so that we can start producing more goods with less input. And this can only happen if we stop subsidizing the cronies and stop rewarding rent-seekers with mega-projects. The culture of meritocracy must also be ingrained so that effort is justly rewarded. Otherwise, how can we produce more with less when lazy buggers are allowed to piggy-back on the hard work of others?

This is what the Economic Transformation Programme should focus on. Not the myriad of capital accumulation projects that Idris Jala can't stop talking about.

Friday, June 15, 2012

The End Of The World As We Know It



2012 has often been touted as the year the world would end. When we think about the end of the world, our minds would typically jump to scenarios that we have seen in movies such as Armageddon, 2012, The Day After Tomorrow or even the Time Machine and Wall-E. Either a meteor heading towards Earth, or insanely volatile climate, or the breaking apart of the moon, or even an alien attack would kill us all. Or at least, it would reset the world to the Ice Age where giant cockroaches ruled the planet.

I must admit, I have pretty much rubbished the claims that the world would end at the end of this year. I might even venture a scoff if you tried to convince me of it. Many of the scenarios from the movies above typically originate from man-made errors. We consumed too much, were too greedy, and we were too late in realizing the error of our ways. Most of the scenarios above were designed in part to scare the living day lights out of us, so that we repent and perhaps start recycling (if you haven’t already), or start driving hybrid cars, etc.

Dani Rodrik, a professor at Harvard University, has a different take on how the world would end. His version depicts the beginning of the end from a less likely source, albeit still man-made. He extends the great European debacle into a apocalyptic scenario where all hell breaks loose and ends with an interesting quote:
Many years later, Merkel, who has withdrawn from politics and become a recluse, is asked whether she thinks that she should have done anything differently during the euro crisis. Unfortunately, her answer comes too late to change the course of history.
The political inaction of the Eurozone leaders will lead to a domino effect that would be the end of us all. Do have a read. What is scary is that, the scenario doesn't seem too far-fetched at all. I had likened the Eurozone crisis as being on the sinking Titanic, but perhaps, I didn't think big enough.

Sunday, May 20, 2012

Volume 14 Issue 20: Intelligent Investing

We Are What We Choose - Jeff Bezos


Below is the Baccalaureate Remarks that Jeff Bezos, the CEO and founder of Amazon, gave at Princeton in 2010. I have included the whole speech, which I think is necessary to read to get the whole context. 

As a kid, I spent my summers with my grandparents on their ranch in Texas. I helped fix windmills, vaccinate cattle, and do other chores. We also watched soap operas every afternoon, especially "Days of our Lives." My grandparents belonged to a Caravan Club, a group of Airstream trailer owners who travel together around the U.S. and Canada. And every few summers, we'd join the caravan. We'd hitch up the Airstream trailer to my grandfather's car, and off we'd go, in a line with 300 other Airstream adventurers. I loved and worshipped my grandparents and I really looked forward to these trips. On one particular trip, I was about 10 years old. I was rolling around in the big bench seat in the back of the car. My grandfather was driving. And my grandmother had the passenger seat. She smoked throughout these trips, and I hated the smell.

At that age, I'd take any excuse to make estimates and do minor arithmetic. I'd calculate our gas mileage -- figure out useless statistics on things like grocery spending. I'd been hearing an ad campaign about smoking. I can't remember the details, but basically the ad said, every puff of a cigarette takes some number of minutes off of your life: I think it might have been two minutes per puff. At any rate, I decided to do the math for my grandmother. I estimated the number of cigarettes per days, estimated the number of puffs per cigarette and so on. When I was satisfied that I'd come up with a reasonable number, I poked my head into the front of the car, tapped my grandmother on the shoulder, and proudly proclaimed, "At two minutes per puff, you've taken nine years off your life!"

I have a vivid memory of what happened, and it was not what I expected. I expected to be applauded for my cleverness and arithmetic skills. "Jeff, you're so smart. You had to have made some tricky estimates, figure out the number of minutes in a year and do some division." That's not what happened. Instead, my grandmother burst into tears. I sat in the backseat and did not know what to do. While my grandmother sat crying, my grandfather, who had been driving in silence, pulled over onto the shoulder of the highway. He got out of the car and came around and opened my door and waited for me to follow. Was I in trouble? My grandfather was a highly intelligent, quiet man. He had never said a harsh word to me, and maybe this was to be the first time? Or maybe he would ask that I get back in the car and apologize to my grandmother. I had no experience in this realm with my grandparents and no way to gauge what the consequences might be. We stopped beside the trailer. My grandfather looked at me, and after a bit of silence, he gently and calmly said, "Jeff, one day you'll understand that it's harder to be kind than clever."

What I want to talk to you about today is the difference between gifts and choices. Cleverness is a gift, kindness is a choice. Gifts are easy -- they're given after all. Choices can be hard. You can seduce yourself with your gifts if you're not careful, and if you do, it'll probably be to the detriment of your choices.

This is a group with many gifts. I'm sure one of your gifts is the gift of a smart and capable brain. I'm confident that's the case because admission is competitive and if there weren't some signs that you're clever, the dean of admission wouldn't have let you in.

Your smarts will come in handy because you will travel in a land of marvels. We humans -- plodding as we are -- will astonish ourselves. We'll invent ways to generate clean energy and a lot of it. Atom by atom, we'll assemble tiny machines that will enter cell walls and make repairs. This month comes the extraordinary but also inevitable news that we've synthesized life. In the coming years, we'll not only synthesize it, but we'll engineer it to specifications. I believe you'll even see us understand the human brain. Jules Verne, Mark Twain, Galileo, Newton -- all the curious from the ages would have wanted to be alive most of all right now. As a civilization, we will have so many gifts, just as you as individuals have so many individual gifts as you sit before me.

How will you use these gifts? And will you take pride in your gifts or pride in your choices?

I got the idea to start Amazon 16 years ago. I came across the fact that Web usage was growing at 2,300 percent per year. I'd never seen or heard of anything that grew that fast, and the idea of building an online bookstore with millions of titles -- something that simply couldn't exist in the physical world -- was very exciting to me. I had just turned 30 years old, and I'd been married for a year. I told my wife MacKenzie that I wanted to quit my job and go do this crazy thing that probably wouldn't work since most startups don't, and I wasn't sure what would happen after that. MacKenzie (also a Princeton grad and sitting here in the second row) told me I should go for it. As a young boy, I'd been a garage inventor. I'd invented an automatic gate closer out of cement-filled tires, a solar cooker that didn't work very well out of an umbrella and tinfoil, baking-pan alarms to entrap my siblings. I'd always wanted to be an inventor, and she wanted me to follow my passion.

I was working at a financial firm in New York City with a bunch of very smart people, and I had a brilliant boss that I much admired. I went to my boss and told him I wanted to start a company selling books on the Internet. He took me on a long walk in Central Park, listened carefully to me, and finally said, "That sounds like a really good idea, but it would be an even better idea for someone who didn't already have a good job." That logic made some sense to me, and he convinced me to think about it for 48 hours before making a final decision. Seen in that light, it really was a difficult choice, but ultimately, I decided I had to give it a shot. I didn't think I'd regret trying and failing. And I suspected I would always be haunted by a decision to not try at all. After much consideration, I took the less safe path to follow my passion, and I'm proud of that choice.

Tomorrow, in a very real sense, your life -- the life you author from scratch on your own -- begins.

How will you use your gifts? What choices will you make?

Will inertia be your guide, or will you follow your passions?

Will you follow dogma, or will you be original?

Will you choose a life of ease, or a life of service and adventure?

Will you wilt under criticism, or will you follow your convictions?

Will you bluff it out when you're wrong, or will you apologize?

Will you guard your heart against rejection, or will you act when you fall in love?

Will you play it safe, or will you be a little bit swashbuckling?

When it's tough, will you give up, or will you be relentless?

Will you be a cynic, or will you be a builder?

Will you be clever at the expense of others, or will you be kind?

I will hazard a prediction. When you are 80 years old, and in a quiet moment of reflection narrating for only yourself the most personal version of your life story, the telling that will be most compact and meaningful will be the series of choices you have made. In the end, we are our choices. Build yourself a great story. Thank you and good luck!
I think from the anecdote that Jeff Bezos shared, it is clear that being smart is not enough. I would imagine it would be very difficult to find anyone who is smarter than Jeff Bezos. But I think what Bezos' grandfather said to him speaks volumes:
"Jeff, one day you'll understand that it's harder to be kind than clever."
I will write more about this area in the future, especially since I have read quite a decent amount on the subject mostly in preparation for the next phase of my life.

Nonetheless. not to get too sidetracked with the whole point of Bezos' story. Life is most certainly full of choices and I truly believe in what he said. Our lives will be the sum of our choices. Every difficult twist and turn you take throughout your lives will lead finally lead you to where you eventually deserve to be.

There really are not shortcuts. Initially, perhaps in the short term, no harm is done. But when you take a shortcut. sometimes, it can come back and bite you far into the future. By taking shortcuts, you are most likely to be shortchanging yourself. Everything that is worth doing, is worth doing well.


Friday, May 18, 2012

Volume 4 Issue 19: Intelligent Investing

Sacrifice of the Haves for the Have-nots


I've been meaning to share this article by Andrew Sheng for a while. It is an interesting read throughout. Here are some parts that Andrew Sheng talks about that ties in to the Western Delusion that any practice that is "un-Western" is not good enough. Here are some interesting excerpts:
In particular, the rise of emerging markets has challenged traditional Western deductive and inductive logic. Deductive inference enables us to predict effects if we know the principles (the rule) and the cause. By inductive reasoning, if we know the cause and effects, we can infer the principles. 
Eastern thinking, by contrast, has been abductive, moving from pragmatism to guessing the next steps. Abductive inference is pragmatic, looking only at outcomes, guessing at the rule, and identifying the cause. 
Like history, social-scientific theory is written by the victors and shaped by the context and challenges of its time. Free-market thinking evolved from Anglo-Saxon theorists (many from Scotland), who migrated and colonized territories, allowing fortunate individuals to assume that there were no limits to consumption. European continental thinking, responding to urbanization and the need for social order, emphasized institutional analysis of political economy. 
Thus, the emergence of neoclassical economics in the nineteenth century was very much influenced by Newtonian and Cartesian physics, moving from qualitative analysis to quantifying human behavior by assuming rational behavior and excluding uncertainty. This “predetermined equilibrium” thinking – reflected in the view that markets always self-correct – led to policy paralysis until the Great Depression, when John Maynard Keynes’s argument for government intervention to address unemployment and output gaps gained traction.
...

New thinking is required to manage these massive and systemic changes, as well as the integration of giants like China and India into the modern world. A change of mindset is needed not just in the West, but also in the East. In 1987, the historian Ray Huang explained it for China:
 
“As the world enters the modern era, most countries under internal and external pressure need to reconstruct themselves by substituting the mode of governancerooted in agrarian experience with a new set of rules based on commerce.…This is easier said than done. The renewal process could affect the top and bottom layers, and inevitably it is necessary to recondition the institutional links between them. Comprehensive destruction is often the order; and it may take decades to bring the work to completion.”

Using this macro-historical framework, we can see Japanese deflation, European debt, and even the Arab Spring as phases of systemic changes within complex structures that are interacting with one another in a new, multipolar global system. We are witnessing simultaneous global convergence (the narrowing of income, wealth, and knowledge gaps between countries) and local divergence (widening income, wealth, and knowledge gaps within countries).
...
A new wave of what the economist Joseph Schumpeter famously called “creative destruction” is under way: even as central banks struggle to maintain stability by flooding markets with liquidity, credit to business and households is shrinking. We live in an age of simultaneous fear of inflation and deflation; of unprecedented prosperity amid growing inequality; and of technological advancement and resource depletion. 
Meanwhile, existing political systems promise good jobs, sound governance, a sustainable environment, and social harmony without sacrifice – a paradise of self-interested free riders that can be sustained only by sacrificing the natural environment and the welfare of future generations.
We cannot postpone the pain of adjustment forever by printing money. Sustainability can be achieved only when the haves become willing to sacrifice for the have-nots.
I particularly like that last sentence. This is precisely what economics is all about. Resources are limited (i.e. not infinite). If control over resources (be it monetary or otherwise) is concentrated in the hands of the wealthy and powerful etc., then sustainability cannot be achieved. I am not advocating a completely egalitarian society, but the need for re-balancing can no longer be ignored. Germany has prospered from the formation of the Eurozone, while the periphery rode along its coat tails. Now that the region is in dire need of unity, why can't Germany play its role as a Eurozone member and sacrifice a little for the have-nots? It may seem like an exaggeration, but the health of the global economy depends on it.

Wednesday, May 16, 2012

Volume 4 Issue 18: Intelligent Investing

Burma's Turn. When Is It Malaysia's Turn?

I kept this article from quite a while back but didn't manage to write anything meaningful about it. Nonetheless, it is a Stiglitz piece, and it would be a shame if I did not share it. Stiglitz talks about Burma (or now known as Myanmar) and its prospects after the leadership change which brought forth a string of rapid reform measures that makes Najib's reform measures look bad. Here is some extract:
Under the leadership of the new president, Thein Sein, the authorities have responded to calls for a political and economic opening. Progress has been made on peace agreements with ethnic-minority insurgents – conflicts rooted in the divide-and-rule strategy of colonialism, which the country’s post-independence rulers maintained for more than six decades. The Nobel laureate Daw Aung San Suu Kyi was not only released from house arrest, but is now campaigning hard for a parliamentary seat in April’s by-elections. 
On the economic front, unprecedented transparency has been introduced into the budgetary process. Expenditures on health care and education have been doubled, albeit from a low base. Licensing restrictions in a number of key areas have been loosened. The government has even committed itself to moving towards unifying its complicated exchange-rate system. 
The spirit of hope in the country is palpable, though some older people, who saw earlier moments of apparent relaxation of authoritarian rule come and go, remain cautious. Perhaps that is why some in the international community are similarly hesitant about easing Myanmar’s isolation. But most Burmese sense that if changes are managed well, the country will have embarked on an irreversible course.
I think the question that is so mind-boggling is, if countries like Myanmar and Senegal can do it, what is stopping Malaysia from implementing meaningful reforms? Are we so short of ideas? You know it is worrying when your Prime Minister has to set up a website to seek ideas on how to improve the country.

Thursday, May 03, 2012

What Successful People Do Differently

This is the transcript of an interview that was taken from the Harvard Business Review on what successful people do differently. Granted it is a very long read, but in a grand scheme of things, I would consider this a very small amount of time and effort to invest in your search for success:
SARAH GREEN: Welcome to the HBR IdeaCast from Harvard Business Review. I'm Sarah Green. What makes successful people different? Today we're talking about some of the strategies of people who are great at what they do, with Heidi Grant Halvorson, a motivational psychologist and author of the new ebook Nine Things Successful People Do Differently. That's also the title of a blog post she wrote for hbr.org which has become far and away our most popular blog post of all time. Heidi, it's so great to have you on the program today.

HEIDI GRANT HALVORSON:Thanks, Sarah.

SARAH GREEN: So first I wanted to ask you just about the genesis of this list of the nine habits of successful people, because some people have seven habits, other people have six keys, maybe someone else has five principles. So how did you settle on these nine things, and what are they based on?

HEIDI GRANT HALVORSON: Basically, the idea, for me, came from my background as a research psychologist. I come from sort of an academic background doing research on-- and the questions I was always interested in had to do with-- why some people handle difficulty better than other people do, why some people seem to be able to set goals and reach them, and other people set goals for themselves and end up not quite making it. And the answers to me were very interesting, because they're counter-intuitive. I think, particularly in the United States and in Western countries in general, we talk a lot about, we think a lot about, ability as the main explainer of success-- that if someone is very successful, they're at the top of their game, it's because they have some talent, some genius that we think of as innate, something they were born with. And that turns out to be surprisingly wrong.

Really, success, more than anything else, turns out to be about being able to set goals and reach them because you use the right strategies. And for, I think, a lot of very successful people, they kind of figure that out as they go along almost intuitively, that some kinds of strategies work for them and others don't. But I thought it'd be great to make this knowledge explicit for people and say, look, here are the nine things-- and really that number, nine, just came from me taking a look at several decades worth of research on motivation-- and saying, what are the strategies that really stand out, that we've tested again and again and found them to be the most effective, to have the biggest impact on whether or not people actually reach their goals? So it was sort of saying, what would give you the most bang for your buck?

And it just turned out to be nine. Nine things that we know from really many, many studies really make a difference. And the other thing I liked about these particular strategies that I talk about is that they're pretty straightforward in terms of once you understand what it is you're not doing, and what you need to do differently, it's fairly easy to implement these changes in your life. And really, knowledge is the key. I think for many of us, we just don't understand where we're going wrong. And why, in some areas of our lives, we seem to be very successful. In other areas we have trouble, and we don't quite understand what the difference is. So these are the nine things that really make the biggest difference.

SARAH GREEN: So one of the strategies that successful people employ is focusing on getting better rather than being good. And that's sort of feel-good, but isn't it important to really be good at something to be successful at it?

HEIDI GRANT HALVORSON: Absolutely. You know, I am glad you brought this up, because it's something that I end up talking about a lot with people. Because I really want to emphasize again and again that this is a research-based argument. So there are a lot of people out there, particularly when it comes to motivation, saying things that sound great, the kinds of things you want to hear. Like, just think positive things and everything will work out for you. And then it turns out to not really be true. But this is one of these cases where what sounds good actually turns out to be the most effective kind of mindset you can have. And so I talk about the difference between when you're doing something-- whether you're tackling a new project, or setting a goal for yourself, or taking on some challenging task, thinking about what you're doing in terms of getting better. In other words, it's about progress, rather than doing it perfectly right out of the gate.

And it turns out in many studies we've been able to show that when people think about what they're doing, whether they're taking a very difficult test of some kind, or working on a project over weeks at a time, that when they think about that as something they're going to improve on, that they're going to develop over time, that they might make mistakes along the way. But that's OK because you learn from those mistakes, and over time you'll really come to master this. When that's the mindset you're taking with you when you approach a task, you actually perform better.

The irony is, if you allow yourself to make mistakes you make fewer of them. And that has a lot to do with the fact that when we expect perfection of ourselves, and we expect to do something, regardless of how difficult it is or how new it is to us, when we expect to do it perfectly right out of the gate, we make tons of mistakes. Because we're anxious, and nothing messes up performance quite like anxiety does. So you feel tense, you're worried, you feel like you're being evaluated, and that really disrupts performance. So this attitude of, I'm going to get the hang of it eventually if I keep trying and keep working at it, actually does result in far superior performance. Particularly when things are very difficult and challenging.

SARAH GREEN: So the idea of steady improvement is so ingrained into your whole approach that some of the things you argue we can improve actually were things I always thought were innate. One of these, for instance, is having grit. That's also on your list as one of the strategies that people use. How can we actually go about making ourselves grittier?

HEIDI GRANT HALVORSON: Grittier, yeah. You actually run into the same argument about the getting better mindset, that people say, well, if I don't think that way, how can I become somebody who thinks that way? And the truth is that all of these things are very malleable. So even the mindset that you approach a task with is something that you can change over time. So the more you keep telling yourself, I'm going to think about this in terms of growth, I'm going to think about this in terms of improvement, then that becomes the new habit over time. And it's the same thing with grit. We tend to think about grittiness, which is basically persistence in pursuit of long term goals, being able to bear down and hang in there when the going gets tough, and not give up on yourself. So grit, it's tempting to think that is something that is kind of innate, that some people are gritty and others aren't. And that again turns out to not be the case.

Grit is something that is learned. And we find that grittiness really comes from, in many ways, your underlying beliefs about the nature of ability. So if you believe that you can get smarter, you can become more creative, you can become a better leader, you can become more socially skilled, you can become a better communicator, if you believe that human abilities are things that grow with effort and experience, it kind of makes you naturally gritty. Because when things become difficult you say, all right, this is really an opportunity for me to develop this skill. And if I just hang in there eventually I can master this. We find that the people who lack grit tend to be those who believe that abilities are fixed, that you sort of either win the DNA lottery or you don't. And you are born smart, or you're born creative, or you're born a good leader or you're not. And so when they encounter difficulty and things are challenging to them, that don't come easily, they are very quick to conclude, well, I guess I'm just not good at this. I guess I lack this ability. And so they give up. So grit really is just fundamentally about hanging in there. And that turns out to be really more than anything else a function of whether or not you believe you can improve.

Now if you're somebody who in the past has tended to think of your abilities as sort of fixed, and tended to say, oh, I'm just not good at this and given up on yourself, then what I encourage you to do is read the book, or read some other things that people, not just myself, but other people in psychology have written about. Abilities, as it turns out, abilities don't work that way at all. We have now decades of research showing that intelligence is profoundly malleable. It grows absolutely with experience and with effort, that creativity is something that also can be developed. Self-control can be developed, and that's another thing I talk about.

One of the nine things is working on your self-control muscle, that idea that willpower is not something that's innate. It can be developed. Leadership skills can be developed. Social skills can be developed. There are no skills, there are no human abilities that cannot be developed. So once you embrace that and realize you've been, maybe without realizing it, believing some things that weren't true about your own ability it becomes much easier to really become a gritty person.

SARAH GREEN: I'm glad you mentioned the idea of strengthening your willpower muscle. The way you talk about that is kind of surprising. This idea that as you're working towards getting better at something like improving your willpower you may actually temporarily exhaust your so-called muscle on willpower. How do you work towards getting better at something in a way, like on willpower, that makes it so that you keep moving forward instead of that suddenly you just crack and dive into the box of doughnuts or whatever?

HEIDI GRANT HALVORSON: Well, I think many of the strategies that I talk about are related to each other. I think again, with willpower you need to take the long view, that this is something you're going to develop over time. We have really several problems when it comes to willpower. One is that we don't understand how it works. Again, this willpower turns out to be one of these things people often assume you either have or you don't. You see the people, the very skinny vegetarians who are non-smokers, and you say, oh, that person was born with a lot of willpower. And again that's really not how it works. Nobody is born with a lot of willpower. It's developed over time like a muscle. So the first thing we need to do is realize anybody can get more willpower if you feel you don't have enough.

But at the same time willpower is always going to be limited because that's another way in which it's like a muscle. You can, just like your biceps or triceps, you can work them out and you can get them stronger. And you can develop huge biceps and triceps. But it's still always going to be true that after a really long, hard workout those muscles are going to be tired, and they're going to kind of feel like jelly. And so your willpower is like that. You can develop it, you can absolutely get more of it. And there are exercises, literally, you can do that I talk about, ways you can train yourself to have more willpower.

But I think at the same time you need to be thinking about your day, thinking about your life, the goals you're pursuing, the times of day where you're most likely to have low willpower because you've used it up. So for many of us that's immediately after work. You spend all day putting out fires, and dealing with stressors, and your willpower's going to be at its lowest. It needs a little bit of time to rebound. So that's going to be a time you're very susceptible to temptation.

And then we need to make plans, which is another thing I talk about among the nine things, plan how you're going to deal with that low willpower. So rather than just saying, oh well, I'll just resist temptation, don't put yourself in harm's way. Instead, come up with an alternative. Something you can do that's going to keep you out of harm's way when temptation abounds and your willpower's low. So it's about building the muscle while still being smart about how it works, and protecting yourself really, when you need to.

SARAH GREEN: So in the blog post, and then at greater length with more detail on exercises in the ebook, you talk about these nine strategies as positive ways to move forward and improve and move toward success in achieving your goals. Are there things though that are counterproductive that you see people doing, kind of shooting themselves in the foot, strategies we should avoid?

HEIDI GRANT HALVORSON: Absolutely. There are a bunch, and unfortunately there are a lot of people kind of advocating for these strategies, and I think with good intentions, because they seem like they should work. One of the things that you hear a lot about among people in the self-help literature, and then in the business world too, is this importance of a positive outlook, that optimism is so important, and that positive thinking will get you everywhere, that if you just sort of visualize the success that you want it will manifest itself. And that would be great if that were true. I mean really, I would absolutely love it if that were true.

But it turns out that not only is it not true in the sense that there is absolutely no evidence that if you visualize yourself in a successful position that that will just somehow materialize, it'll just happen. In fact, actually there's now good evidence that that kind of thinking actually sabotages your success. So in other words, when people are only positive in their thinking-- they're sort of wild-eyed optimists, they're unrealistic optimists, they just focus on the positive and they don't think at all, don't allow themselves to think about the obstacles that need to be overcome in order to make that dream a reality-- that actually they're less likely to succeed. And it has everything to do with this idea that, the way I talk about it, is sort of that visualizing success is bad. The idea is really you need to visualize the steps you need to take to make success happen.

So I still think of my message as sort of optimistic, in the sense that what I'm telling people is they really can be more successful then they are currently if they apply these strategies. But that said, it involves thinking seriously about what your obstacles are, what kind of problems might derail you and figuring out how you're going to deal with those problems. That's how you make success happen. Some people call that negative thinking, thinking about obstacles, thinking about what could go wrong, coming up with a Plan B. That kind of thinking gets, I think, a bad rap. But really it's a very critical part of being successful. Really successful people are what I call realistic optimists. They believe they can succeed, which is very important. But they believe that they're going to have to make that happen by thinking very realistically about the problems that lie in their way. So that's, I think, one example of the kind of strategy that's out there, this sort of relentless positive thinking that really sabotages people.

And related to that is, I think, this idea that we think a little bit too much about when it comes-- especially to trying to change our behavior. So to, say, stop flying off the handle and losing your temper when people, your colleagues, irritate you, or if you want to stop smoking or stop snacking. We think a lot about what we're not going to do. And we really focus on that. So I'm not going to smoke, I'm not going to lose my temper, I'm not going to eat the doughnuts in the conference room. And what we really need to be doing-- again, there's been recently quite a bit of research showing that this focusing on not doing things actually ends up being very counterproductive. And it has to do with, I think, a lot of people may be familiar with this idea, of thought suppression, that don't think about white bears idea, that when you tell yourself don't think about white bears, suddenly all you can think about is white bears. So there's this ironic rebounding that happens when you try to suppress a thought, that it kind of comes back into your mind. And it turns out the same thing happens with behavior. So if you say I'm not going to lose my temper, I'm not going to eat these doughnuts, then suddenly all you want to do is lose your temper and eat doughnuts. And it turns out that people who make those kinds of resolutions end up doing more of the thing that they promised themselves they wouldn't do.

So the key becomes, actually, instead of saying what you won't do, say what you will do instead. So instead of saying I won't lose my temper, say OK, well, the next time my colleague irritates me I'm going to step aside and take three deep breathes and remind myself that it's not worth getting angry over. Or instead of having a cigarette, I'm going to chew some gum. Or instead of having a doughnut I'm going to go make myself a cup of tea. So it's the what you will do instead part that turns out to be very powerful.

Our brains like to have an action plan. And they don't like plans that are in the form of I won't do x. They want to know what you will do, and those plans turn out to be very effective. So the strategies that are effective often turn out to be just sort of subtle changes to things we're already doing. Planning is great, and we all know planning is great, but you need to plan in the right way. Being optimistic is great. Thinking about believing in yourself is great. But you have to engage in positive thinking in the right way. And so for many of the things that I talk about in the Nine Things, it's really saying look, there's more than one way to plan. There's more than one way to be positive. There's more than one way to think about willpower. Here's the ways to do these things that are really going to pay off, that are really going to lead to greater success.

SARAH GREEN: Heidi, thanks again so much for talking with us today.

HEIDI GRANT HALVORSON: Thank you so much, Sarah.

SARAH GREEN: That was Heidi Grant Halvorson. Her new ebook, Nine Things Successful People Do Differently, is available wherever digital books are sold. For more, visit hbr.org


Tuesday, May 01, 2012

Volume 4 Issue 17: Intelligent Investing

How To Be A Remarkable Employee?


For many of us that are just transitioning from college to working adult life, we would probably, for the first time, encounter our quarter-life crisis. For quite possibly our whole lives, we were told to study hard, get a good job and you will make a lot of money.

What many of us don't realize is that in the first three years of working, none of what was promised to us is true. You studied your butts off, and you got a good job but where is the money? Some of us even believe that as long as we did the above-mentioned things, we would be entitled to a high-paying job.

Before long, reality will soon smack you in the face. Getting a good job is not an end itself. It does not lead to a high paying job. You will soon realize that if you want to earn a high pay, you would have to work hard for it as well. After a while, you would realize that you are stuck in this rat race:
How many times have you asked yourself that question, or some other similar version of it? Waking up at 7.30 a.m. to go to work and returning past dinnertime every weekday just to keep your family fed. As Monday begins, you look forward to Friday, AGAIN. Some of you even dread Sundays because tomorrow is Monday. Weekends are a whole lot of fun because you get to watch TV, hang out with friends, or do whatever it is that you do. To make things worse, after all that, when you receive your paycheck at the end of the month, you feel only two seconds of joy as it dawns upon you that you have to pay your rent, your bills (electricity, telephone, internet, handphone and god knows what else), your wife (for her to buy groceries and necessities for your family because she quit her job to take care of your children; you refused to hire a maid because you want the best environment for your children) and the list goes on. By the time you subtract all these expenses, you are afraid to even look at the balance that remains. Maybe that’s why you don’t keep account of your expenditure. Does the above sound like you? Granted, most of my readers have not had a family yet but I hope the story is something you can relate to.
Subsequently, you begin to think that your job is not for you, simply because you do not find any job satisfaction in it. We often complain about our jobs and how we are not being appreciated for doing something that was not within our job scope in the first place. You look for an occupation change in search of a higher pay, better benefits and less working hours. Soon after, you will realize that the cycle has continued. For the few of you who are lucky enough to have found an occupation you love, you excel at it. But more often than not, we are not so lucky.  We slog through the grind, telling ourselves "We do what we have to do, so that we can do what we want to do". We then often ask ourselves, "What happened to the dream that was promised to us if we had studied hard and got a good job?"

How many times will we keep on blaming our surroundings and our jobs before we realize that the only thing we can change is ourselves. By that, I mean our very own attitude and how we perceive the things around us. So, we finally arrive at our agenda for the day. Here is an article to help you stand out and in order to become a remarkable employee. I advise that you read through this carefully and take the message to heart in your approach towards your career, and perhaps with a little bit of luck, you may finally find the elusive job satisfaction that you have been hunting for:
Great employees are reliable, dependable, proactive, diligent, great leaders and great followers... they possess a wide range of easily-defined—but hard to find—qualities. 
A few hit the next level. Some employees are remarkable, possessing qualities that may not appear on performance appraisals but nonetheless make a major impact on performance. 
Here are eight qualities of remarkable employees: 
1. They ignore job descriptions. The smaller the company, the more important it is that employees can think on their feet, adapt quickly to shifting priorities, and do whatever it takes, regardless of role or position, to get things done. 
When a key customer's project is in jeopardy, remarkable employees know without being told there's a problem and jump in without being asked—even if it's not their job. 
2. They’re eccentric... The best employees are often a little different: quirky, sometimes irreverent, even delighted to be unusual. They seem slightly odd, but in a really good way. Unusual personalities shake things up, make work more fun, and transform a plain-vanilla group into a team with flair and flavor. 
People who aren't afraid to be different naturally stretch boundaries and challenge the status quo, and they often come up with the best ideas. 
3. But they know when to dial it back. An unusual personality is a lot of fun... until it isn't. When a major challenge pops up or a situation gets stressful, the best employees stop expressing their individuality and fit seamlessly into the team. 
Remarkable employees know when to play and when to be serious; when to be irreverent and when to conform; and when to challenge and when to back off. It’s a tough balance to strike, but a rare few can walk that fine line with ease. 
4. They publicly praise... Praise from a boss feels good. Praise from a peer feels awesome, especially when you look up to that person. 
Remarkable employees recognize the contributions of others, especially in group settings where the impact of their words is even greater. 
5. And they privately complain. We all want employees to bring issues forward, but some problems are better handled in private. Great employees often get more latitude to bring up controversial subjects in a group setting because their performance allows greater freedom. 
Remarkable employees come to you before or after a meeting to discuss a sensitive issue, knowing that bringing it up in a group setting could set off a firestorm. 
6. They speak when others won’t. Some employees are hesitant to speak up in meetings. Some are even hesitant to speak up privately. 
An employee once asked me a question about potential layoffs. After the meeting I said to him, “Why did you ask about that? You already know what's going on.” He said, “I do, but a lot of other people don't, and they're afraid to ask. I thought it would help if they heard the answer from you.” 
Remarkable employees have an innate feel for the issues and concerns of those around them, and step up to ask questions or raise important issues when others hesitate. 
7. They like to prove others wrong. Self-motivation often springs from a desire to show that doubters are wrong. The kid without a college degree or the woman who was told she didn't have leadership potential often possess a burning desire to prove other people wrong. 
Education, intelligence, talent, and skill are important, but drive is critical. Remarkable employees are driven by something deeper and more personal than just the desire to do a good job. 
8. They’re always fiddling. Some people are rarely satisfied (I mean that in a good way) and are constantly tinkering with something: Reworking a timeline, adjusting a process, tweaking a workflow. 
Great employees follow processes. Remarkable employees find ways to make those processes even better, not only because they are expected to… but because they just can't help it. 


Saturday, April 07, 2012

Volume 4 Issue 14: Intelligent Investing

The Malaysian Delusion

It's very difficult to be a Malaysian. One of the reasons is that, very often, we get compared with Singaporeans and are told how well they are doing. I mean, I am one of those people who probably compares Malaysia with Singapore a bit too much.

Very often, people point out that Malaysia is a much larger country compared with Singapore, which is why it is more difficult to manage. Singapore has a much smaller population, so it has less mouths to feed. That's why people there are richer. This is all a bunch of hogwash. 

Let us consider a very simple example. Korea has a population of about 49 million people, about 1.75 times that of Malaysia. It also has a much smaller land area (about 100,000 square km) compared with Malaysia's abundant land space (about 330,000 square km). This also means that Malaysia has more resources and space to grow. Malaysia is also not located next to North Korea, which boasts all sorts of nuclear weapons which can be seen as all kinds of threats to its sovereignty. 

But look at the economic performance of Korea in the last 30 years or so. Korea's GDP per capita was almost at par with that of Malaysia in 1980, but is now almost triple that of Malaysia - see chart 1.

Chart 1
And here we have our Bank Negara Annual Report (White Box - pdf) claiming that the Malaysian economy is doing well as it has managed to diversify further by relying less on manufacturing. This is ridiculous because Korea has an even larger dependence on manufacturing compared with Malaysia - see chart 2.

Chart 2
The real weakness is that Malaysia is becoming less and less competitive and is no longer able to attract low-end manufacturers as wages in Malaysia have kept on increasing without commensurate increase in productivity. Furthermore, it does not have enough skilled workers to attract high-end manufacturers. One of the most impressive achievements that Korea has made over the past 30 years is the little known fact (maybe it is just my ignorance) that Koreans have focused strongly on education. In chart 3 (source: OECD), we can see that more than 60% of young Koreans (25-34 year-olds) have attained tertiary education. This is in contrast with the older generation of Koreans (55-64 year-olds) whereby less than 15% have attained tertiary education.

Chart 3
The improvement is nothing short of tremendous. It is by far the best among all OECD countries. What is interesting to note is that the US actually went in reverse, recording a lower proportion of young people with tertiary education compared with the older generation.

This is one of the core factors that allow high-end manufacturing the thrive in Korea. Of course, in Malaysia, the amount of people with tertiary education has surged, but what kind of graduates are we getting? As Tony Pua wrote in his book, "The Tiger That Lost Its Roar", Malaysia has 20 public universities, 24 private universities and 21 "university colleges" to serve its "small" population of 28 million. That translates to about 430,000 people per university. In comparison, Singapore, which has about 5 million people, has only three universities. This translates to about 1.7 million people per university.

Sadly, the quantity of universities say nothing about the quality of Malaysian graduates. The quality of some of the universities are so bad that the graduates are deemed unfit to enter the workforce. So why is the Deputy Prime Minister still in denial about the poor quality of our education system?

In short, this myth about Singapore being an easier country to manage is just nonsense. Even a much more populated country like Korea which lacks the natural resources that Malaysia has can transform itself into a high income economy. The important lesson here is that in order to improve, we have to stop living in denial and start looking for where we went wrong. 


Thursday, April 05, 2012

For Students Who Think Their Professors Are Evil


From Professor Art Carden (from a long time ago, but I never got around to posting it):
One of the popular myths of higher education is that professors are sadists who live to inflict psychological trauma on undergraduates. Perhaps you believe that we pick students at random and then schedule all our assignments in such a way as to make those students’ lives as difficult as possible. The older I get and the longer I do this, the more I recognize that we (the professors) need to be more transparent about our philosophies of evaluation.

...
 
...the burden of proof is on you to demonstrate that you have mastered the material. It is not on me to demonstrate that you have not. My assumption at the beginning of each class is that you know somewhere between nothing and very little about basic economics unless you were lucky enough to have an exceptional high school economics course. Otherwise, why are you here?

That said, you should never take grades personally. I don’t think you’re stupid because you tank an exam, an assignment, or even an entire course. Economics is hard. A D or an F on an economics exam does not diminish your value in God’s eyes (or in mine) or indicate that economics just isn’t for you. It probably means you need to work smarter, and I’m here to help you with that.


Tuesday, March 06, 2012

Blast From The Past

Since I have not got around to posting my thoughts on these issues, and some of them are getting a little out of date, I am just going to share the links here for archiving purposes. They are good reads and definitely worth thinking about. 

1. Rise of the Technocrats?
Is the European Union’s supposed “democratic deficit” now spreading to individual European countries in the wake of the sovereign-debt crisis? The rise of unelected technocrats to political power in Greece and Italy suggests, at least superficially, that the old taboo against technocratic governments pursuing an EU-dictated agenda has been shattered.
2. The Philippines - Malaysia's New Competitor?
The Philippines reopened for business under new management only a little more than a year ago. It is faring very well – and is set to become increasingly profitable.
3. Just a chart on the desirability and earnings potential of different college majors in the US
P/S: Anyone else find it shocking the Geology and Earth Sciences is listed under Arts?
4. Why Art majors are being subsidized (refer to No.3 for more)
ALEX TABARROK, a George Mason economist and blogger at Marginal Revolution, notes that though many more young Americans, about 50% more, now go to college than did 25 years ago, the number of students studying science, engineering, technology, or mathematics has not increased. So, Mr Tabarrok asks, "If students aren’t studying science, technology, engineering and math, what are they studying?" They are studying interesting and enjoyable fields, it turns out. Mr Tabarrok reports, with no little dread:

"In 2009 the U.S. graduated 89,140 students in the visual and performing arts, more than in computer science, math and chemical engineering combined and more than double the number of visual and performing arts graduates in 1985."
This is worrisome because diseases go uncured and potential gains in purchasing power are left unrealised as America's apple-cheeked human capital squanders itself staging the "Vagina Monologues". Mr Tabarrok admits there's nothing exactly wrong with young Americans learning how to play the euphonium, he just doubts this fluff is worth subsidizing. Growth-enhancing disruptive innovation doesn't come from villanelles!

"[G]raduates in the arts, psychology and journalism are less likely to create the kinds of innovations that drive economic growth. Economic growth is not a magic totem to which all else must bow, but it is one of the main reasons we subsidize higher education.
 
The potential wage gains for college graduates go to the graduates — that’s reason enough for students to pursue a college education. We add subsidies to the mix, however, because we believe that education has positive spillover benefits that flow to society. 
One of the biggest of these benefits is the increase in innovation that highly educated workers theoretically bring to the economy... 
There is little justification for subsidizing sociology, dance and English majors." 
As a consequence, Mr Tabarrok thinks that "the taxpayers who foot the bill for these subsidies" are being ill used.
5. Here is Tabarrok's full post: College Has Been Oversold

6. Why Debt Is Not The Real Problem in Greece, But Competitiveness Is

7. One Year in Prison Costs More Than One Year at Princeton



Friday, March 02, 2012

Robbing The Poor To Pay The Rich?

This is exactly what it is:
Last week, the American International Group reported a whopping $19.8 billion profit for its fourth quarter. It was a quite a feat for a company that was on its death bed just a little over three years ago, so sick that it needed a huge taxpayer bailout.
But if you dug into the numbers, it quickly became clear that $17.7 billion of that profit was pure fantasy — a tax benefit, er, gift, from the United States government. The company made only $1.6 billion during the quarter from actual operations. Yet A.I.G. not only received a tax benefit, it is unlikely to pay a cent of taxes this year, nor by some estimates, for at least a decade. 
The tax benefit is notable for more than simply its size. It is the result of a rule that the Treasury unilaterally bent for A.I.G. and several other hobbled companies in 2008 that has largely been overlooked.

This rule-twisting could deprive the government of tens of billions of dollars, assuming the firm remains profitable. The tax dodge — and let’s be honest, that’s what it is — also will most likely help goose the bonuses of A.I.G.’s employees, some of whom helped create many of the problems that led to its role in the financial crisis.


Sunday, February 19, 2012

Volume 4 Issue 7: Intelligent Investing

Civil Service Wages - One Step Forward, Two Steps Back



Another way to put this is that the government is not only shooting itself in the foot. It is also shooting Malaysia in the face. 

In the guise of "raising" public sector wages, the government had once again served the interests of the people in the top echelons of public service:
The Malaysian Insider understands that Putrajaya wants to completely overhaul the scheme which only seemed to benefit top civil servants but many of an estimated 2,000 senior civil servants have already signed and consented to the new scheme, which guarantees a pay rise of some RM5,000 a month.
Can you believe that some of the civil servants are guaranteed a pay rise of RM5,000 per month? The increase alone is more than most of our monthly incomes. Get this:
The proposal, which sees the highest pay at RM60,000 a month for the Chief Secretary to the Government while those in lower pay grades would receive an increment as low as RM1.70, has ignited anger and disapproval in the 1.4 million-strong civil service — a key vote bank for the ruling Barisan Nasional (BN) coalition — ahead of a general election that must be called by May 2013.
 I don't know how RM1.70 is going to make any difference in a person's life. Clearly the plan was well-thought out. So not only are the "rich" rewarded, but the poor are being marginalized yet again. As if the problem of inequality isn't bad enough.

Long ago, I had already recommended a "wage policy" that was simple and transparent:
It is now rampant that local graduates these days can barely qualify for a job at an MNC, even with the current wage level. I have been taught by graduates with engineering degrees in my secondary school. That was almost eight years ago. The situation is that bad. If you increase the minimum wages in sectors with positive externalities, you could possibly create a productivity multiplier. More people would want to be in these areas. For example, if a teacher's salary were to be increased significantly, more people would want to become teachers. Of course the buck must not stop there. The pay for the people who actually train these teachers have to increase as well. This will result in two things. First, too many people will want to become teachers. Now, this may seem like a bad thing at first. But this is the most fundamental concept of life. Just think about how you were born. Millions of sperm going after one ova. The fittest will survive. In this case, only the best people will get to be teachers. I mean, look at doctors. When you talk to parents, they stereotypically want their children to grow up to be doctors, lawyers and whatever. Why? Because it is a high paying job and not many people get to become doctors.

This competition for survival will push for the selectivity of the people who actually qualify for the profession. Even with the failed-notion of meritocracy in our country (by that, I mean, not all the best people will be selected because of our quota system) there will be an invisible force to select the better few to perform an important job function. The majority of the people who want to become teachers would be sufficiently qualified and so would their trainers.

Now, the second result is where the positive externality comes in. I pause to make an assumption here. I assert that good teachers will increase the number of good students. With more good students who eventually become useful graduates and consequently productive workers in all industries, the economy of our country will be thriving. Think first world thriving.
This proposal also signals to the general public about what jobs does the government think is important. In my opinion, doctors and teachers should come first in order to maintain long-term growth sustainability. We need to keep our population healthy, and we need to keep our population competitive intelectually.

But it goes without saying that any wage increase has to come with proportionate improvement in productivity. And to do this,  the government or the statistics department has to come up with a proper way to measure productivity and collect data on it, just like the US. As I have shared before, one of Bob Parson's 16 rules of success is:
Measure anything of significance
When you start measuring anything and everything that you deem as important, then only can you measure your improvements. If you merely wish to "improve productivity", it does not make sense if you have no way to measure productivity.

All these are just preliminary steps that need to be taken to even come close to reforming the Malaysian economy and society in its path towards high income. All we are hearing now is just lip-service and half-hearted attempts (I also wrote about them in recently, here, here and here) at appeasing the public before the impending elections.

Tuesday, February 14, 2012

Monday, January 30, 2012

Tata Nano: An Inferior Good?


How cheap is too cheap? Apparently, the Tata Nano is too cheap. So much so that people stay away from it just because of its low price:
“A Nano is always bandied about as a poor man’s car. Nobody wants to be caught with it,” said Punnoose Tharyan, editor of India’s Motown magazine.
In economic terms, this would be considered to be an inferior good. The term inferior is somewhat misleading in the sense that it implies that the Nano is of poorer quality. Economists are not a particularly creative species. They do not come up with very good names for economic terms. Another example would be using "utility" to represent satisfaction. And the unit used to measure the amount of satisfaction is "utils".

Essentially, a good is considered "inferior" when the quantity demanded of the good decreases as its price decrease. This is opposed to a "normal" good where quantity demanded increases as its price decrease.